"That's the trouble with anything which essentially has a lot of bits that are physically impossible: You're left, stuck, in the studio. And that's a shame. You're making a movie. You don't want it to stay put, you want it to be a movie - to move"
About this Quote
Coltrane is pricking a very particular kind of modern filmmaking balloon: the kind that replaces the messy, unpredictable world with a clean, controllable one. When “a lot of bits” are “physically impossible,” the production doesn’t just lean on special effects; it starts organizing itself around them. The studio becomes not a tool but a habitat, and the actors - whose craft depends on reacting to real space, real weather, real friction - get sealed into a fluorescent terrarium.
The wit sits in how he defines “movie” in the most literal, almost childlike way: it should “move.” Not just the camera, not just the plot, but the whole enterprise should have kinetic life. Coltrane’s complaint isn’t anti-fantasy; it’s anti-stasis. He’s talking about the way elaborate technical constraints can paradoxically freeze a production. When everything must be composited later, spontaneity becomes a liability. You stop chasing moments and start protecting continuity. Performance gets atomized into fragments that will be “fixed” in post, and the set becomes a waiting room for decisions made by computers.
Context matters: Coltrane worked inside blockbuster machinery (and the fantasy-industrial complex that came with it) while still coming up through traditions that valued physicality and location. The subtext is an actor’s plea for risk: for filmmaking that leaves the building, bumps into reality, and lets accidents become texture. He’s not nostalgic for inconvenience; he’s insisting that cinema’s magic isn’t the impossible image - it’s the feeling that something alive is happening right now.
The wit sits in how he defines “movie” in the most literal, almost childlike way: it should “move.” Not just the camera, not just the plot, but the whole enterprise should have kinetic life. Coltrane’s complaint isn’t anti-fantasy; it’s anti-stasis. He’s talking about the way elaborate technical constraints can paradoxically freeze a production. When everything must be composited later, spontaneity becomes a liability. You stop chasing moments and start protecting continuity. Performance gets atomized into fragments that will be “fixed” in post, and the set becomes a waiting room for decisions made by computers.
Context matters: Coltrane worked inside blockbuster machinery (and the fantasy-industrial complex that came with it) while still coming up through traditions that valued physicality and location. The subtext is an actor’s plea for risk: for filmmaking that leaves the building, bumps into reality, and lets accidents become texture. He’s not nostalgic for inconvenience; he’s insisting that cinema’s magic isn’t the impossible image - it’s the feeling that something alive is happening right now.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|
More Quotes by Robbie
Add to List
