"The death penalty is discriminatory and does not do anything about crime"
About this Quote
Bobby Scott’s line lands with the clipped clarity of a committee hearing sound bite: two charges, no ornament, maximum moral and political payload. By pairing “discriminatory” with “does not do anything about crime,” he refuses the usual trade-off capital punishment advocates depend on, where inequality is treated as an unfortunate side effect of “public safety.” Scott’s intent is to collapse that bargain. If the policy is both unjust in application and ineffective in outcome, then the state’s ultimate punishment isn’t merely harsh - it’s irrational.
The first clause is aimed at legitimacy. “Discriminatory” invokes the well-documented racial, geographic, and economic skew in who gets sentenced to death, and it quietly indicts the system’s gatekeepers: prosecutors’ discretion, juries’ biases, the quality of defense counsel, and the uneven politics of counties that pursue capital cases. Scott doesn’t need to name any demographic group; the word carries its own evidentiary shadow, especially coming from a lawmaker long associated with civil rights and criminal justice reform.
The second clause targets the mythic utility of the death penalty. “Does not do anything about crime” is deliberately blunt, signaling impatience with deterrence rhetoric. It reframes capital punishment as political theater: a ritual of toughness that satisfies a desire for retribution while leaving the conditions that produce violence untouched. In the contemporary context - amid shifting public opinion, DNA exonerations, and a growing emphasis on systemic inequity - the line functions less as persuasion-by-nuance than as a boundary marker: this is the reformist position, stripped to its most defensible essentials.
The first clause is aimed at legitimacy. “Discriminatory” invokes the well-documented racial, geographic, and economic skew in who gets sentenced to death, and it quietly indicts the system’s gatekeepers: prosecutors’ discretion, juries’ biases, the quality of defense counsel, and the uneven politics of counties that pursue capital cases. Scott doesn’t need to name any demographic group; the word carries its own evidentiary shadow, especially coming from a lawmaker long associated with civil rights and criminal justice reform.
The second clause targets the mythic utility of the death penalty. “Does not do anything about crime” is deliberately blunt, signaling impatience with deterrence rhetoric. It reframes capital punishment as political theater: a ritual of toughness that satisfies a desire for retribution while leaving the conditions that produce violence untouched. In the contemporary context - amid shifting public opinion, DNA exonerations, and a growing emphasis on systemic inequity - the line functions less as persuasion-by-nuance than as a boundary marker: this is the reformist position, stripped to its most defensible essentials.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Bobby
Add to List
