"The greater the state, the more wrong and cruel its patriotism, and the greater is the sum of suffering upon which its power is founded"
About this Quote
Tolstoy doesn’t treat patriotism as a warm feeling; he frames it as an instrument that scales with the size of the machine. The line is built like a grim equation: as the state grows, so does the cruelty required to keep people emotionally invested in it. “Greater” isn’t praise here, it’s a warning label. In Tolstoy’s moral universe, bigness demands abstraction, and abstraction makes violence easier to sell. You can’t ask millions to kill, pay, and comply on the strength of neighborly affection. You need myth, ritual, and an enemy.
The subtext is a demolition of the sentimental story nations tell about themselves. Patriotism isn’t merely misused by bad governments; it becomes “more wrong” by design because it has to override ordinary ethics. The bigger the state, the more it needs citizens to confuse loyalty with virtue and obedience with dignity. The word “founded” is doing heavy work: power isn’t maintained by suffering, it’s built on it, like a palace set on bones.
Context matters. Tolstoy wrote in the shadow of imperial Russia, conscription, and the nationalist fervor that turned modern war into a mass civic project. After his spiritual turn, he became ferociously anti-militarist, skeptical of state authority, and allergic to the church-and-flag fusion that blessed violence as duty. The sentence lands because it refuses the comfortable exception: it doesn’t say patriotism can be corrupted; it says scale itself corrupts it. In an age that equated nationhood with progress, Tolstoy offers a colder thesis: the price of “greatness” is paid by someone else, and patriotism is the receipt.
The subtext is a demolition of the sentimental story nations tell about themselves. Patriotism isn’t merely misused by bad governments; it becomes “more wrong” by design because it has to override ordinary ethics. The bigger the state, the more it needs citizens to confuse loyalty with virtue and obedience with dignity. The word “founded” is doing heavy work: power isn’t maintained by suffering, it’s built on it, like a palace set on bones.
Context matters. Tolstoy wrote in the shadow of imperial Russia, conscription, and the nationalist fervor that turned modern war into a mass civic project. After his spiritual turn, he became ferociously anti-militarist, skeptical of state authority, and allergic to the church-and-flag fusion that blessed violence as duty. The sentence lands because it refuses the comfortable exception: it doesn’t say patriotism can be corrupted; it says scale itself corrupts it. In an age that equated nationhood with progress, Tolstoy offers a colder thesis: the price of “greatness” is paid by someone else, and patriotism is the receipt.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Leo
Add to List











