"The important thing is not so much that every child should be taught, as that every child should be given the wish to learn"
About this Quote
A Victorian statesman arguing that schooling isn’t the same thing as education is quietly picking a fight with his own era’s favorite fix: compulsion. Lubbock’s line pivots on a deceptively small contrast - “taught” versus “given the wish.” One is mechanical, measurable, and easy to legislate. The other is interior, unpredictable, and politically inconvenient. In that sense, the quote is less a warm sentiment than a critique of reform-by-spreadsheet: you can mandate attendance, standardize lessons, and still produce citizens who comply without curiosity.
The subtext is liberal and strategic. Lubbock isn’t dismissing instruction; he’s warning that instruction without desire creates brittle knowledge - information that doesn’t travel when the teacher leaves the room. “Wish” is doing heavy rhetorical work. It recasts learning as agency rather than ingestion, positioning the child as an active participant instead of a vessel. For a statesman, that’s also a model of citizenship: people who can govern themselves because they’ve practiced self-directed attention.
Context matters. Late 19th-century Britain was expanding mass education alongside industrial discipline: punctuality, uniformity, examinations. Lubbock’s emphasis on appetite rather than apparatus pushes back against an education system that risks mirroring the factory. The intent is reformist but not utopian: if the goal is social mobility, productivity, or democratic competence, the lever isn’t only curriculum - it’s motivation. He’s telling policymakers that the hardest part of education can’t be ordered from the top down, only cultivated.
The subtext is liberal and strategic. Lubbock isn’t dismissing instruction; he’s warning that instruction without desire creates brittle knowledge - information that doesn’t travel when the teacher leaves the room. “Wish” is doing heavy rhetorical work. It recasts learning as agency rather than ingestion, positioning the child as an active participant instead of a vessel. For a statesman, that’s also a model of citizenship: people who can govern themselves because they’ve practiced self-directed attention.
Context matters. Late 19th-century Britain was expanding mass education alongside industrial discipline: punctuality, uniformity, examinations. Lubbock’s emphasis on appetite rather than apparatus pushes back against an education system that risks mirroring the factory. The intent is reformist but not utopian: if the goal is social mobility, productivity, or democratic competence, the lever isn’t only curriculum - it’s motivation. He’s telling policymakers that the hardest part of education can’t be ordered from the top down, only cultivated.
Quote Details
| Topic | Study Motivation |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List
