"The men are much alarmed by certain speculations about women; and well they may be, for when the horse and ass begin to think and argue, adieu to riding and driving"
About this Quote
A wry, barbed observation turns the politics of gender into the language of stable and road. Men are alarmed by new ideas about women because their dominance has depended on a presumption of silent compliance. The image of the horse and the ass is not a slur on women but a pinpoint of how society has treated them: as useful, obedient creatures, guided, harnessed, and steered. If such creatures begin to think and argue, the rider loses his seat. Control has always looked effortless when the mount is trained to submit; once the mind awakens, adieu to riding and driving.
Adelaide Anne Procter wrote in mid-Victorian Britain, where the doctrine of separate spheres, coverture laws, and limited education kept women legally and intellectually constrained. She was a popular poet, published by Dickens in Household Words and All the Year Round, and a social reformer who advocated for womens work and dignity. Her line slips a radical claim into a memorable metaphor: the true engine of subordination is the denial of thought, and the true instrument of emancipation is argument. No threats, no upheaval, merely the quiet revolution of reasoning aloud.
The humor is strategic. By couching a sharp critique in domestic imagery, Procter exposes the paternalistic fantasy that domination is natural. Riding is pleasurable only while the ridden cannot object. The moment women claim the right to speculate, to test ideas, to debate, the old order reveals itself as a posture maintained by habit, not principle. The sentence also answers a recurring Victorian anxiety that female education would unsex women or unravel society. Procter suggests that what will truly end is not society but a particular privilege: the ease with which men direct others without challenge. The line is both diagnosis and prophecy, catching the tipping point where thought becomes agency and comfort must yield to justice.
Adelaide Anne Procter wrote in mid-Victorian Britain, where the doctrine of separate spheres, coverture laws, and limited education kept women legally and intellectually constrained. She was a popular poet, published by Dickens in Household Words and All the Year Round, and a social reformer who advocated for womens work and dignity. Her line slips a radical claim into a memorable metaphor: the true engine of subordination is the denial of thought, and the true instrument of emancipation is argument. No threats, no upheaval, merely the quiet revolution of reasoning aloud.
The humor is strategic. By couching a sharp critique in domestic imagery, Procter exposes the paternalistic fantasy that domination is natural. Riding is pleasurable only while the ridden cannot object. The moment women claim the right to speculate, to test ideas, to debate, the old order reveals itself as a posture maintained by habit, not principle. The sentence also answers a recurring Victorian anxiety that female education would unsex women or unravel society. Procter suggests that what will truly end is not society but a particular privilege: the ease with which men direct others without challenge. The line is both diagnosis and prophecy, catching the tipping point where thought becomes agency and comfort must yield to justice.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sarcastic |
|---|
More Quotes by Adelaide
Add to List
