"There are the further difficulties of building a population out of a diversity of races, each at a different stage of cultural evolution, some in need of restraint, many in need of protection; everywhere a bewildering Babel of tongues"
About this Quote
Arthur Keith's quote presents a perspective on the sociocultural characteristics of diverse populations, particularly worrying the challenges fundamental in building a cohesive society amidst substantial racial and cultural distinctions. It shows an age's view, likely from a colonial or post-colonial context, where societies were coming to grips with the integration of varied ethnic groups, each having unique cultural qualities and historic backgrounds.
The phrase "diversity of races, each at a various stage of cultural advancement" suggests a hierarchical view of cultures, implying that some races or ethnic groups were perceived as being more "sophisticated" or "civilized" than others. This perspective is emblematic of a now-outdated anthropological approach that viewed cultures through a direct evolutionary lens. Such thinking typically justified paternalistic policies and colonial supremacy, under the guise of boosting less "innovative" cultures.
The idea that some groups are "in need of restraint" while many require "protection" brings an implication of superiority and inability. The idea of "restraint" suggests control over those deemed as lacking in self-governance or perceived as possibly disruptive. Meanwhile, the principle of "protection" might suggest a paternalistic obligation to protect minority groups viewed as susceptible or incapable of self-sufficiency.
The "bewildering Babel of tongues" metaphorically references the scriptural story of the Tower of Babel, representing confusion and miscommunication resulting from linguistic variety. This highlights the difficulties in accomplishing social cohesion and effective interaction across different language groups.
In general, while Keith's quote highlights genuine obstacles in multicultural integration, it also reflects a time-specific and Eurocentric worldview. Modern interpretations prefer a more egalitarian method, commemorating multiculturalism as a strength and prioritizing shared respect, understanding, and cooperation amongst all cultural groups to construct inclusive societies. This shift acknowledges the complexities of cultural combination while upholding the self-respect and firm of all individuals no matter their racial or cultural backgrounds.