"There is no nation so powerful, as the one that obeys its laws not from principals of fear or reason, but from passion"
About this Quote
Montesquieu is smuggling a dangerous compliment into what sounds like civic wisdom: the strongest nation is not the one with the best police, nor even the best arguments, but the one whose citizens feel the law in their bones. He sets up a three-part ladder - fear, reason, passion - and then pulls the rung out from under Enlightenment complacency. Fear is brute compliance; reason is the tidy fantasy that people can be talked into virtue like theyre balancing a ledger. Passion is stickier. It fuses obedience with identity.
The subtext is that law, to endure, has to become culture. Montesquieu is writing in a France where authority is loudly sacralized but quietly gamed, where the state depends on spectacle and coercion, and where the emerging Enlightenment faith in rational reform hasnt yet met the realities of mass politics. His point is less "be emotional" than "recognize what actually moves populations". People will outmaneuver surveillance and ignore syllogisms; they will march, sacrifice, and self-police when they believe the law expresses who they are.
Theres irony here, too: passion is the engine of stability and the seed of catastrophe. The same affective bond that makes a society cohesive can harden into fanaticism, turning obedience into a kind of romantic submission. Montesquieu, the theorist of moderation and separated powers, is warning that institutions alone are not enough; they require a moral climate. The most powerful nation, in his bleakly practical view, is the one that turns legality into love - and knows how easily love can curdle.
The subtext is that law, to endure, has to become culture. Montesquieu is writing in a France where authority is loudly sacralized but quietly gamed, where the state depends on spectacle and coercion, and where the emerging Enlightenment faith in rational reform hasnt yet met the realities of mass politics. His point is less "be emotional" than "recognize what actually moves populations". People will outmaneuver surveillance and ignore syllogisms; they will march, sacrifice, and self-police when they believe the law expresses who they are.
Theres irony here, too: passion is the engine of stability and the seed of catastrophe. The same affective bond that makes a society cohesive can harden into fanaticism, turning obedience into a kind of romantic submission. Montesquieu, the theorist of moderation and separated powers, is warning that institutions alone are not enough; they require a moral climate. The most powerful nation, in his bleakly practical view, is the one that turns legality into love - and knows how easily love can curdle.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List
