"To teach a man how he may learn to grow independently, and for himself, is perhaps the greatest service that one man can do another"
About this Quote
Education here isn’t a transfer of knowledge so much as a controlled relinquishing of power. Jowett’s line makes a quietly radical claim: the highest form of help is the kind that makes the helper obsolete. The phrasing matters. “Teach a man how he may learn” stacks verbs like a set of nested doors, insisting that the real skill is meta-skill: not answers, but the capacity to generate them. “Grow independently” adds a moral charge. Independence isn’t framed as rebellious self-expression; it’s maturity, a disciplined autonomy that can withstand authority, fashion, and inherited belief.
The subtext is a critique of paternalism dressed as benevolence. Plenty of institutions claim to “serve” people by managing them - intellectually, spiritually, politically. Jowett, a theologian and famed Oxford tutor (and a controversial one for applying historical criticism to Scripture), is arguing for a kind of mentorship that refuses to confuse guidance with control. Coming from within a tradition built on doctrine and deference, that’s the tell: he’s defending a model of faith and learning that can survive scrutiny, because it invites scrutiny.
There’s also Victorian class and gender baked into “a man,” but the mechanism generalizes: empowerment as pedagogy, not charity. “Perhaps the greatest service” is cautious, almost diplomatic, yet it lands as a hierarchy of virtues. Feed someone, instruct someone, rescue someone - admirable, but temporary. Teach them to learn for themselves, and you’ve moved from solving a problem to changing a life’s operating system.
The subtext is a critique of paternalism dressed as benevolence. Plenty of institutions claim to “serve” people by managing them - intellectually, spiritually, politically. Jowett, a theologian and famed Oxford tutor (and a controversial one for applying historical criticism to Scripture), is arguing for a kind of mentorship that refuses to confuse guidance with control. Coming from within a tradition built on doctrine and deference, that’s the tell: he’s defending a model of faith and learning that can survive scrutiny, because it invites scrutiny.
There’s also Victorian class and gender baked into “a man,” but the mechanism generalizes: empowerment as pedagogy, not charity. “Perhaps the greatest service” is cautious, almost diplomatic, yet it lands as a hierarchy of virtues. Feed someone, instruct someone, rescue someone - admirable, but temporary. Teach them to learn for themselves, and you’ve moved from solving a problem to changing a life’s operating system.
Quote Details
| Topic | Teaching |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Benjamin
Add to List











