"What do you think a stimulus is? It's spending - that's the whole point! Seriously"
About this Quote
There is a deliberately blunt civics lesson hiding inside that exasperated “Seriously.” Obama isn’t trying to be eloquent here; he’s trying to be unmistakable. In a debate where “stimulus” had been rhetorically laundered into something suspicious, wasteful, or abstract, he drags it back to its plain meaning: government puts money into the economy to get demand moving. The intent is corrective, almost parental, as if he’s cutting through cable-news fog with a whiteboard marker.
The subtext is sharper. By framing it as a question - “What do you think a stimulus is?” - Obama positions critics as either confused or bad-faith actors who want the benefits of recovery without admitting the mechanism. “It’s spending” isn’t just a definition; it’s a dare. If you oppose spending categorically, then you’re opposing the tool itself, not “pork” around the edges. He’s forcing a choice: argue about what to spend on, or admit you don’t want stimulus at all.
Context matters: this is the post-crash political economy, when “government spending” had become a cultural trigger phrase and austerity was marketed as prudence. Obama, the professor-president stereotype his opponents loved to caricature, flips the script by refusing technocratic euphemisms. The clipped cadence and the emphatic “that’s the whole point!” are rhetorical shock tactics - a moment of impatience designed to travel, to be quoted, to puncture the myth that recovery can be conjured without cost.
The subtext is sharper. By framing it as a question - “What do you think a stimulus is?” - Obama positions critics as either confused or bad-faith actors who want the benefits of recovery without admitting the mechanism. “It’s spending” isn’t just a definition; it’s a dare. If you oppose spending categorically, then you’re opposing the tool itself, not “pork” around the edges. He’s forcing a choice: argue about what to spend on, or admit you don’t want stimulus at all.
Context matters: this is the post-crash political economy, when “government spending” had become a cultural trigger phrase and austerity was marketed as prudence. Obama, the professor-president stereotype his opponents loved to caricature, flips the script by refusing technocratic euphemisms. The clipped cadence and the emphatic “that’s the whole point!” are rhetorical shock tactics - a moment of impatience designed to travel, to be quoted, to puncture the myth that recovery can be conjured without cost.
Quote Details
| Topic | Money |
|---|
More Quotes by Barack
Add to List

