"Whatever deceives men seems to produce a magical enchantment"
About this Quote
Deception, Plato suggests, is not just effective; its effectiveness feels like sorcery. The line is doing double duty: it diagnoses a psychological weakness and takes a jab at the social machinery that exploits it. People don’t merely fall for lies; they experience them as enchantment, a pleasurable suspension of judgment that masquerades as insight.
The intent is recognizably Platonic: to warn that appearances can hijack the soul. In the Republic and related dialogues, Plato is preoccupied with the power of mimesis (imitation) and rhetoric to move crowds without educating them. “Magical” is not a compliment. It’s a pointed metaphor for influence that bypasses reason, working like a spell: quick, seductive, and resistant to refutation because it satisfies desire before it answers questions. The subtext is almost elitist in its severity: most people are not simply uninformed, they are primed to prefer the comforting copy to the demanding original. Truth requires discipline; deception offers narrative, certainty, and the warm glow of being right.
Context matters: Plato is writing in the aftermath of Athens’ political turmoil and the trial of Socrates, in a culture where skilled speakers could sway juries and assemblies. “Enchantment” captures what he feared about democratic publics and sophisticated persuaders: the ability to produce conviction without knowledge. Read now, it lands as an early theory of virality. The most “magical” messages aren’t the most accurate; they’re the ones engineered to feel irresistible.
The intent is recognizably Platonic: to warn that appearances can hijack the soul. In the Republic and related dialogues, Plato is preoccupied with the power of mimesis (imitation) and rhetoric to move crowds without educating them. “Magical” is not a compliment. It’s a pointed metaphor for influence that bypasses reason, working like a spell: quick, seductive, and resistant to refutation because it satisfies desire before it answers questions. The subtext is almost elitist in its severity: most people are not simply uninformed, they are primed to prefer the comforting copy to the demanding original. Truth requires discipline; deception offers narrative, certainty, and the warm glow of being right.
Context matters: Plato is writing in the aftermath of Athens’ political turmoil and the trial of Socrates, in a culture where skilled speakers could sway juries and assemblies. “Enchantment” captures what he feared about democratic publics and sophisticated persuaders: the ability to produce conviction without knowledge. Read now, it lands as an early theory of virality. The most “magical” messages aren’t the most accurate; they’re the ones engineered to feel irresistible.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Plato
Add to List









