"When I came to Congress, like our first panel, small business people, 64 percent of the people had health insurance. We'd buy it. Now, we're down to about 34 percent. That's why we have to do something on health care in this country because the cost is killing us"
About this Quote
Stupak frames health care reform the way a shop owner would talk about a busted balance sheet: not as an ideology, but as a cost spiral that’s eating the business alive. The numbers do the heavy lifting. By opening with “When I came to Congress,” he stakes credibility through time served, then anchors the debate in a before-and-after story that feels like decline, not theory. The shift from 64 percent to 34 percent isn’t just a statistic; it’s a narrative of erosion, a warning that what used to be normal is now untenable.
The small-business angle is strategic. Big employers can negotiate; individuals can sometimes scrape by; small businesses get squeezed in the middle, too large to ignore benefits, too small to absorb premium hikes. By aligning himself with “our first panel,” he’s also borrowing legitimacy from testimony and lived experience, implying this isn’t a partisan talking point but evidence already on the record. “We’d buy it” carries a quiet rebuke to the idea that uninsured workers are simply irresponsible. They were customers. The product became unaffordable.
The subtext is coalition-building. He’s signaling to fiscal conservatives and business-friendly Democrats: you don’t have to love government to admit the market is failing this segment. “We have to do something” is deliberately non-specific, leaving room for different policy paths while insisting on urgency. The blunt closer - “the cost is killing us” - recasts reform as survival, not compassion, and turns economic pain into political mandate.
The small-business angle is strategic. Big employers can negotiate; individuals can sometimes scrape by; small businesses get squeezed in the middle, too large to ignore benefits, too small to absorb premium hikes. By aligning himself with “our first panel,” he’s also borrowing legitimacy from testimony and lived experience, implying this isn’t a partisan talking point but evidence already on the record. “We’d buy it” carries a quiet rebuke to the idea that uninsured workers are simply irresponsible. They were customers. The product became unaffordable.
The subtext is coalition-building. He’s signaling to fiscal conservatives and business-friendly Democrats: you don’t have to love government to admit the market is failing this segment. “We have to do something” is deliberately non-specific, leaving room for different policy paths while insisting on urgency. The blunt closer - “the cost is killing us” - recasts reform as survival, not compassion, and turns economic pain into political mandate.
Quote Details
| Topic | Health |
|---|
More Quotes by Bart
Add to List
