"You cannot spend your way out of recession or borrow your way out of debt"
About this Quote
Daniel Hannan’s assertion, “You cannot spend your way out of recession or borrow your way out of debt,” challenges the notion of counter-cyclical government spending and questions fiscal stimulus as a remedy for economic downturns. His first claim, about spending and recession, critiques Keynesian economics, which advocates for increased public expenditure during periods of low private demand. Hannan’s perspective reflects concern that such spending merely postpones necessary adjustments, possibly exacerbates inefficiencies, and creates artificial demand without addressing underlying structural weaknesses within the economy.
When governments inject money through expansive fiscal policies, the resources must come from somewhere, typically through increased debt or higher taxes, either immediately or in the future. The short-term boost in economic activity is often accompanied by long-term consequences, such as inflation, misallocation of resources, or persistent budget deficits. Hannan’s skepticism arises from the belief that real economic recovery results from restoring confidence, competitiveness, and sustainable production rather than relying on state intervention that could stifle private sector dynamism.
The second part of his statement critiques the notion of solving indebtedness by borrowing more, akin to a household taking new loans to pay off old ones. This cycle potentially leads to a debt spiral, reducing fiscal room to maneuver, increasing interest payments, and threatening creditworthiness. The argument asserts that true solvency derives from fiscal responsibility, balancing budgets, pursuing prudent spending, and fostering economic conditions for organic growth rather than temporary, debt-fueled consumption.
Underlying Hannan’s argument is a belief in limited government intervention and in the importance of market forces and individual initiative in economic healing. While critics contend that government intervention can soften downturns and prevent deep social pain, Hannan emphasizes the risks of dependency and long-term fiscal imprudence. To him, durable prosperity results from discipline, not debt accumulation or continuous public spending.
About the Author