"A friend should be one in whose understanding and virtue we can equally confide, and whose opinion we can value at once for its justness and its sincerity"
About this Quote
Friendship here is treated less like a vibe and more like an ethical contract. Robert Hall, a Baptist minister writing in an age that prized moral character as public currency, gives you a definition that quietly polices the boundaries of intimacy. The friend he describes is not simply enjoyable; he is safe. "Understanding and virtue" are paired like twin locks on the same door: empathy without integrity is merely cleverness, and virtue without understanding becomes sanctimony. Hall insists you need both before you "confide" which, in his register, means more than sharing secrets. It means entrusting the self.
The real bite is in what he refuses to include. No mention of fun, loyalty, or shared history. Hall's ideal friend functions as a moral instrument: someone whose judgment you can submit to without fear of manipulation or performative piety. The friend must be able to tell you the truth and be the sort of person whose truth-telling isn't a power play.
His final clause is a neat piece of rhetorical carpentry: we value a friend's opinion for "justness" (its accuracy, fairness) and "sincerity" (its motive). Modern culture often separates those traits, celebrating "brutal honesty" even when it's unkind, or valuing supportive affirmation even when it's delusional. Hall won't let you pick. The subtext is pastoral: friendship, for him, is partly a safeguard against self-deception, a private form of accountability grounded not in surveillance but in trust.
The real bite is in what he refuses to include. No mention of fun, loyalty, or shared history. Hall's ideal friend functions as a moral instrument: someone whose judgment you can submit to without fear of manipulation or performative piety. The friend must be able to tell you the truth and be the sort of person whose truth-telling isn't a power play.
His final clause is a neat piece of rhetorical carpentry: we value a friend's opinion for "justness" (its accuracy, fairness) and "sincerity" (its motive). Modern culture often separates those traits, celebrating "brutal honesty" even when it's unkind, or valuing supportive affirmation even when it's delusional. Hall won't let you pick. The subtext is pastoral: friendship, for him, is partly a safeguard against self-deception, a private form of accountability grounded not in surveillance but in trust.
Quote Details
| Topic | Friendship |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
