"A revolution can be neither made nor stopped. The only thing that can be done is for one of several of its children to give it a direction by dint of victories"
About this Quote
Napoleon frames revolution as a force of nature: not a policy choice, not a moral debate, not even a conspiracy you can arrest. You dont "make" it because it erupts from accumulated pressure; you dont "stop" it because once legitimacy cracks, every attempt to restore the old order reads as weakness, nostalgia, or repression. That fatalism is doing political work. It quietly absolves the speaker of responsibility for the chaos while claiming mastery over its outcome.
The sharp turn comes with the metaphor of "children". Revolutions, in Napoleons telling, spawn heirs: factions, generals, committees, demagogues. They fight not to end the upheaval but to inherit it. The subtext is brutally pragmatic: ideals dont steer history; wins do. "Direction" doesnt come from constitutions or speeches but from "dint of victories" - repeated, material proof that you can impose order. In other words, authority is retroactively justified by success.
Context matters because Napoleon is not theorizing from the sidelines. He is the archetypal revolutionary beneficiary who later crowns himself emperor. This line reads like a memo from inside the machine: the thermidorian lesson that once the center collapses, politics becomes a contest over who can stabilize the new reality fastest. Its also a warning to would-be moderates: neutrality is not an option when the state is melting. If you dont seize the revolution, it will be seized for you.
Rhetorically, it recasts ambition as duty. The conqueror becomes the "child" merely giving direction - history made inevitable, empire made managerial.
The sharp turn comes with the metaphor of "children". Revolutions, in Napoleons telling, spawn heirs: factions, generals, committees, demagogues. They fight not to end the upheaval but to inherit it. The subtext is brutally pragmatic: ideals dont steer history; wins do. "Direction" doesnt come from constitutions or speeches but from "dint of victories" - repeated, material proof that you can impose order. In other words, authority is retroactively justified by success.
Context matters because Napoleon is not theorizing from the sidelines. He is the archetypal revolutionary beneficiary who later crowns himself emperor. This line reads like a memo from inside the machine: the thermidorian lesson that once the center collapses, politics becomes a contest over who can stabilize the new reality fastest. Its also a warning to would-be moderates: neutrality is not an option when the state is melting. If you dont seize the revolution, it will be seized for you.
Rhetorically, it recasts ambition as duty. The conqueror becomes the "child" merely giving direction - history made inevitable, empire made managerial.
Quote Details
| Topic | Vision & Strategy |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: Top Inspiring Thoughts of Napoleon Buonaparte (M.D. Sharma, 2021) modern compilationID: e-sFEAAAQBAJ
Evidence: ... A revolution can be neither made nor stopped . The only thing that can be done is for one of several of its children to give it a direction by dint of victories . 11. A revolution is an idea which has found its bayonets . 12. A soldier ... Other candidates (1) Arthur Wellesley, 1st Duke of Wellington (Napoleon Bonaparte) compilation36.0% e real question that now divides the country and which truly divides the house of commons is church or no church peop... |
More Quotes by Napoleon
Add to List








