"Be yourself is about the worst advice you can give to some people"

J.B. Priestley’s assertion that “Be yourself is about the worst advice you can give to some people” invites a critical examination of what it means to embrace one’s authentic self. Common wisdom often elevates self-expression and authenticity as universal virtues, suggesting that happiness, success, and moral fulfillment lie in simply being true to oneself. However, Priestley challenges this premise, suggesting that, for certain individuals, unfiltered self-expression may not yield positive outcomes, either for themselves or for the people around them.

Some personalities possess traits or tendencies that may be harmful, deeply negative, or socially disruptive if left unchecked. For instance, a person who is naturally aggressive, selfish, or prejudiced might interpret the advice to “be yourself” as a license to act on those impulses without regard for personal growth, self-reflection, or consideration for others. In such cases, encouraging someone to be themselves can become an abdication of the responsibility to challenge destructive behaviors and guide them toward positive change.

Furthermore, the process of self-improvement often requires individuals to confront their flaws and actively strive to become better, more considerate members of society. Telling someone to just “be yourself” can sometimes serve as an endorsement of stagnation, suggesting that change is unnecessary or even undesirable. The advice can impede social and personal development, implying that authenticity is more important than accountability or empathy. Society functions smoothly not simply because everyone acts on their impulses, but because individuals learn to balance personal desires with shared values, empathy, and respect for others.

Priestley’s perspective prompts a reconsideration of authenticity as an unqualified good. Self-awareness, growth, and social harmony often require restraint, adaptability, and a willingness to become someone better than one’s starting point. Sometimes, the best guidance is not to merely be oneself, but to thoughtfully refine and transcend one’s lesser instincts in pursuit of something greater.