"Brute animals have the vowel sounds; man only can utter consonants"
About this Quote
Coleridge takes a seemingly technical claim about speech and turns it into a miniature manifesto about what separates humans from the rest of nature: not feeling, not instinct, but articulation. Vowels are breath and music, the open-throated sound you can imagine in a cow’s lowing or a bird’s call. Consonants are friction, stops, edges - the mouth doing deliberate work. He’s not really lecturing on phonetics; he’s staging a Romantic hierarchy where raw sound belongs to “brute animals” and structured language belongs to “man.”
The intent is pointedly civilizational. Consonants imply segmentation, grammar’s building blocks, the capacity to carve experience into units that can be named, argued over, and remembered. If vowels are the warm continuum of sensation, consonants are the technology of thought: the hard clicks that let you make distinctions, assign responsibility, legislate, pray, write poems. Coleridge’s phrasing “man only” signals the period’s confidence (and its exclusions) - a human exceptionalism that doubles as a moral claim.
The subtext, though, is that poetry itself lives in the tension he’s describing. Romantic poets fetishized the “natural” music of voice, but they also depended on craft: meter, consonance, the disciplined shaping of breath into meaning. Coleridge is quietly defending artifice as our most intimate nature. Even his crude animal/human split is doing rhetorical work: it flatters the reader as a creature of consonants, a being whose rough little sounds can become reason, law, and lyric.
The intent is pointedly civilizational. Consonants imply segmentation, grammar’s building blocks, the capacity to carve experience into units that can be named, argued over, and remembered. If vowels are the warm continuum of sensation, consonants are the technology of thought: the hard clicks that let you make distinctions, assign responsibility, legislate, pray, write poems. Coleridge’s phrasing “man only” signals the period’s confidence (and its exclusions) - a human exceptionalism that doubles as a moral claim.
The subtext, though, is that poetry itself lives in the tension he’s describing. Romantic poets fetishized the “natural” music of voice, but they also depended on craft: meter, consonance, the disciplined shaping of breath into meaning. Coleridge is quietly defending artifice as our most intimate nature. Even his crude animal/human split is doing rhetorical work: it flatters the reader as a creature of consonants, a being whose rough little sounds can become reason, law, and lyric.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Samuel
Add to List
