"'Emergencies' have always been the pretext on which the safeguards of individual liberty have been eroded"
About this Quote
Hayek’s line works because it treats “emergency” not as a neutral description of danger but as a political instrument: a word that reorders priorities, compresses debate, and turns extraordinary power into common sense. He’s not denying that crises exist; he’s warning that the label itself is a solvent. Once something is called an emergency, the usual burdens of proof flip. The state no longer has to justify intrusion; the individual has to justify resistance.
The scare quotes around “Emergencies” are doing the real work. They suggest elasticity and opportunism: today’s urgent threat, tomorrow’s convenient rationale. Hayek is pointing to a recurring pattern in modern governance: temporary measures that become permanent architecture. Surveillance regimes survive the plot they were built to stop. Wartime controls reappear in peacetime as “regulatory capacity.” Rights aren’t typically abolished with drumrolls; they’re nibbled away under claims of necessity.
Context matters. Writing in the shadow of totalitarianism and world war, Hayek saw how centralized planning and security politics could merge into a single administrative habit: experts, committees, directives, and the moral blackmail of urgency. His broader project in The Road to Serfdom wasn’t libertarian melodrama so much as institutional skepticism: when governments gain discretionary power in a crisis, they also gain the precedent, the bureaucracy, and the temptation to define the next crisis.
The subtext is a challenge to the audience’s own panic. If liberty is only defended when it’s convenient, it’s not a safeguard at all; it’s a luxury item, first pawned when fear spikes.
The scare quotes around “Emergencies” are doing the real work. They suggest elasticity and opportunism: today’s urgent threat, tomorrow’s convenient rationale. Hayek is pointing to a recurring pattern in modern governance: temporary measures that become permanent architecture. Surveillance regimes survive the plot they were built to stop. Wartime controls reappear in peacetime as “regulatory capacity.” Rights aren’t typically abolished with drumrolls; they’re nibbled away under claims of necessity.
Context matters. Writing in the shadow of totalitarianism and world war, Hayek saw how centralized planning and security politics could merge into a single administrative habit: experts, committees, directives, and the moral blackmail of urgency. His broader project in The Road to Serfdom wasn’t libertarian melodrama so much as institutional skepticism: when governments gain discretionary power in a crisis, they also gain the precedent, the bureaucracy, and the temptation to define the next crisis.
The subtext is a challenge to the audience’s own panic. If liberty is only defended when it’s convenient, it’s not a safeguard at all; it’s a luxury item, first pawned when fear spikes.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Unverified source: Law, Legislation and Liberty, Vol. 3: Political Order (Friedrich August von Hayek, 1979)ISBN: 9780226320878
Evidence: Chapter 17, "A Model Constitution" (p. 124 in the 1979 U. Chicago Press ed.). Primary-source location appears to be Hayek’s own text in *Law, Legislation and Liberty*, Volume 3 (*The Political Order of a Free People*). The full sentence is often quoted with an added continuation about emergency p... Other candidates (2) Naturalopy Precept 19: Liberty (Trung Nguyen, 2015) compilation95.0% ... Emergencies have always been the pretext on which the safeguards of individual liberty have been eroded. Friedric... Edmund Burke (Friedrich August von Hayek) compilation37.5% ntific thought have been built up by famous scholars on the fragments that fell from his table great literary fortune... |
More Quotes by Friedrich
Add to List










