"There is nothing with which it is so dangerous to take liberties as liberty itself"
About this Quote
Breton’s line lands like a trapdoor under a word everyone claims to love. “Liberty” usually arrives as a self-justifying halo; he flips it into a volatile substance, something you can mishandle. The slyness is in the phrasing: taking “liberties” is a petty idiom for overstepping, for treating rules as optional. Set against “liberty itself,” the joke turns acidic. The language suggests that freedom is easiest to cheapen precisely when you think you’re celebrating it.
Coming from Breton, this isn’t a conservative warning against emancipation. It’s a Surrealist’s suspicion of how quickly radical energies get appropriated, domesticated, or turned into permission slips for ego. The Surrealists wanted liberation of desire, perception, and politics; Breton also watched factions, manifestos, and purges fracture the very movements that promised freedom. The sentence carries that lived contradiction: liberty isn’t a stable possession but a practice, and “taking liberties” with it can become a moral alibi - a way to excuse coercion, aesthetic vandalism, or political ruthlessness under the banner of being “free.”
Subtextually, he’s diagnosing a recurring cultural move: freedom as brand. When “liberty” becomes a slogan, it’s available for anyone to weaponize - states to justify repression, artists to justify cruelty, movements to justify silencing dissent. The warning is sharp because it refuses comfort. The most dangerous abuse of liberty isn’t the obvious tyrant’s boot; it’s the self-congratulating overreach that arrives with applause and calls itself liberation.
Coming from Breton, this isn’t a conservative warning against emancipation. It’s a Surrealist’s suspicion of how quickly radical energies get appropriated, domesticated, or turned into permission slips for ego. The Surrealists wanted liberation of desire, perception, and politics; Breton also watched factions, manifestos, and purges fracture the very movements that promised freedom. The sentence carries that lived contradiction: liberty isn’t a stable possession but a practice, and “taking liberties” with it can become a moral alibi - a way to excuse coercion, aesthetic vandalism, or political ruthlessness under the banner of being “free.”
Subtextually, he’s diagnosing a recurring cultural move: freedom as brand. When “liberty” becomes a slogan, it’s available for anyone to weaponize - states to justify repression, artists to justify cruelty, movements to justify silencing dissent. The warning is sharp because it refuses comfort. The most dangerous abuse of liberty isn’t the obvious tyrant’s boot; it’s the self-congratulating overreach that arrives with applause and calls itself liberation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Andre
Add to List
