"Facts are not science - as the dictionary is not literature"
About this Quote
Fischer’s line slices through a stubborn modern confusion: the belief that piling up facts automatically produces understanding. The comparison is surgical. A dictionary is a warehouse of words, not the lived experience of language arranged into meaning; literature happens when words are selected, structured, voiced, and made to matter. In the same way, “facts” are raw materials. Science is the craft that turns them into explanations: choosing what to measure, designing tests, building models, arguing over causality, and accepting that today’s neat story might be tomorrow’s discarded draft.
The subtext is a rebuke to two kinds of complacency. One is the positivist fantasy that data speaks for itself, as if numbers arrive pre-interpreted. The other is the armchair skeptic’s move of treating “science” as a mere catalog of verified statements, rather than a method with judgment, uncertainty, and revision baked in. Fischer is insisting on form, not just content. Facts without theory are noise; theory without facts is fiction. Science is where those tensions are negotiated in public, with rules.
Contextually, Fischer wrote in an era when medicine and biology were rapidly professionalizing, drowning in new observations and instruments. His point lands hardest there: clinical “facts” can mislead unless they’re disciplined by experiment and inference. It’s also a warning that feels painfully current in the age of dashboards and hot takes: information abundance is not an epistemology.
The subtext is a rebuke to two kinds of complacency. One is the positivist fantasy that data speaks for itself, as if numbers arrive pre-interpreted. The other is the armchair skeptic’s move of treating “science” as a mere catalog of verified statements, rather than a method with judgment, uncertainty, and revision baked in. Fischer is insisting on form, not just content. Facts without theory are noise; theory without facts is fiction. Science is where those tensions are negotiated in public, with rules.
Contextually, Fischer wrote in an era when medicine and biology were rapidly professionalizing, drowning in new observations and instruments. His point lands hardest there: clinical “facts” can mislead unless they’re disciplined by experiment and inference. It’s also a warning that feels painfully current in the age of dashboards and hot takes: information abundance is not an epistemology.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|
More Quotes by Martin
Add to List



