"Gratitude is a sickness suffered by dogs"
About this Quote
Gratitude is framed here not as a virtue but as a contagion: something that weakens the host and makes it easier to control. Coming from Stalin, the line reads like a miniature doctrine of power. Gratitude implies obligation; obligation implies leverage. If you are grateful, you admit dependency and you owe someone - which, in a paranoid authoritarian imagination, means you can be bought, flipped, or morally compromised. Better to treat gratitude as an animal ailment, an instinctive reflex in creatures trained to obey.
The insult does double work. Calling it a “sickness” medicalizes a human emotion, turning ethics into pathology and implying that a hardened revolutionary must be clinically resistant to sentiment. Calling it “suffered by dogs” turns gratitude into something subhuman and domesticated. Dogs are loyal. Dogs wait for scraps. Dogs wag at the hand that feeds them. Stalin’s subtext: loyalty rooted in appreciation is not loyalty at all; it’s training.
Context matters because Stalin’s political world depended on breaking personal bonds and replacing them with fear and transactional allegiance to the state - or to him. In that environment, gratitude becomes dangerous evidence of private ties: patronage networks, old friendships, debts of honor, independent consciences. Total power prefers clean relationships: commands issued, obedience delivered, no emotional residue. The quote’s cold efficiency is the point. It’s not merely cynical; it’s prophylactic, a warning to subordinates to purge softness and to victims not to expect mercy repaid with thanks.
The insult does double work. Calling it a “sickness” medicalizes a human emotion, turning ethics into pathology and implying that a hardened revolutionary must be clinically resistant to sentiment. Calling it “suffered by dogs” turns gratitude into something subhuman and domesticated. Dogs are loyal. Dogs wait for scraps. Dogs wag at the hand that feeds them. Stalin’s subtext: loyalty rooted in appreciation is not loyalty at all; it’s training.
Context matters because Stalin’s political world depended on breaking personal bonds and replacing them with fear and transactional allegiance to the state - or to him. In that environment, gratitude becomes dangerous evidence of private ties: patronage networks, old friendships, debts of honor, independent consciences. Total power prefers clean relationships: commands issued, obedience delivered, no emotional residue. The quote’s cold efficiency is the point. It’s not merely cynical; it’s prophylactic, a warning to subordinates to purge softness and to victims not to expect mercy repaid with thanks.
Quote Details
| Topic | Gratitude |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: Gratitude and the Good Life (Philip C. Watkins, 2013) modern compilationISBN: 9789400772533 · ID: r4rHBAAAQBAJ
Evidence: ... Joseph Stalin apparently had an even lower view of gratitude. He is said to have declared, “Gratitude is a sickness suffered by dogs.” Perhaps these quotes reflect the Western individualistic attitude that one should be independent and ... Other candidates (1) Joseph Stalin (Joseph Stalin) compilation95.0% ount the votes decide everything gratitude is a sickness suffered by dogs as quo |
More Quotes by Joseph
Add to List








