"Ideas any one can mould as he wishes"
About this Quote
The line compresses a paradox at the heart of Josiah Royces philosophy: thought is pliable, reality is not. Ideas are plastic. They can be shaped by desire, fear, habit, rhetoric, or imagination, and any clever mind can spin them into comforting narratives or persuasive doctrines. That malleability is the source of creativity and insight, but it is also the root of self-deception and manipulation.
Royce, a leading American idealist, held that minds live in a world of meanings. An idea is not a brute fact; it is a sign we interpret. Because interpretation is human work, it admits of revision, embellishment, and distortion. Yet Royce also insisted that error is real, and that the existence of error points beyond our private fancies to a wider order that can correct us. The stubbornness of facts and the discipline of inquiry limit what mere wishing can accomplish. We can mould ideas, but we cannot will them into truth without submitting them to tests set by experience and by a community of interpreters.
That community, for Royce, was ethical as well as epistemic. He argued for loyalty to causes that sustain a shared life of meaning, an ideal sometimes gathered under his notion of the Beloved Community. To mould ideas to suit only one’s private ends is a betrayal of loyalty; to shape them in service of a cause that invites criticism, welcomes correction, and seeks common understanding is an act of intellectual fidelity. The moral is not to distrust ideas because they are malleable, but to accept the responsibility that follows from their malleability. Imagination must be yoked to honesty, and persuasion to accountability.
The line therefore names both a freedom and a duty. Anyone can reshape ideas; few are willing to have their ideas reshaped by evidence, dialogue, and the claims of others. For Royce, wisdom begins where that willingness starts.
Royce, a leading American idealist, held that minds live in a world of meanings. An idea is not a brute fact; it is a sign we interpret. Because interpretation is human work, it admits of revision, embellishment, and distortion. Yet Royce also insisted that error is real, and that the existence of error points beyond our private fancies to a wider order that can correct us. The stubbornness of facts and the discipline of inquiry limit what mere wishing can accomplish. We can mould ideas, but we cannot will them into truth without submitting them to tests set by experience and by a community of interpreters.
That community, for Royce, was ethical as well as epistemic. He argued for loyalty to causes that sustain a shared life of meaning, an ideal sometimes gathered under his notion of the Beloved Community. To mould ideas to suit only one’s private ends is a betrayal of loyalty; to shape them in service of a cause that invites criticism, welcomes correction, and seeks common understanding is an act of intellectual fidelity. The moral is not to distrust ideas because they are malleable, but to accept the responsibility that follows from their malleability. Imagination must be yoked to honesty, and persuasion to accountability.
The line therefore names both a freedom and a duty. Anyone can reshape ideas; few are willing to have their ideas reshaped by evidence, dialogue, and the claims of others. For Royce, wisdom begins where that willingness starts.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Josiah
Add to List
