"It has no enforceable standards to stop a union from conspiring with employers to keep another stronger union out or from negotiating contracts with lower pay and standards that members of another union have spent a lifetime establishing"
About this Quote
Andy Stern's quote addresses a substantial issue within the labor movement about the vulnerability of unions to control and the potential for backdoor agreements that can weaken the efforts of workers. The crux of the declaration depends on the lack of "enforceable standards" that can prevent or penalize actions where unions might conspire with employers for less than worthy purposes-- particularly, to block more powerful unions from representing employees or to consent to inferior agreement terms that damage the achievements of other unions.
First of all, Stern highlights the concern of union solidarity being compromised. Unions, by their very nature, are formed to safeguard employees' rights and improve labor conditions. When a union conspires with employers to keep a stronger union out, it undermines this fundamental purpose. This not just damages the cumulative bargaining power but likewise types distrust amongst employees concerning the motives and integrity of the representation they get.
Furthermore, the referral to working out contracts with "lower pay and standards" targets the erosion of hard-fought gains by other unions. Many unions invest substantial time and resources to enhance incomes, advantages, and working conditions for their members throughout the years. When another union comes in and negotiates weaker terms, it can create a race to the bottom, setting precedents that lower labor standards industry-wide. Such actions can have a cascading result, not just for the instant employees, however across sectors where these lower requirements may be embraced.
In a more comprehensive context, this quote works as a call to action to enhance the systems and guidelines governing labor unions. Enforceable standards are needed to ensure that unions act in the very best interests of their members and follow principles of solidarity and fair representation. Without these safeguards, there's a risk that the labor movement could be co-opted in ways that are detrimental to its main objective of enhancing the lives of workers.
About the Author