"It is not our job to apply laws that have not yet been written"
About this Quote
The quote by John Paul Stevens, "It is not our job to apply laws that have not yet been written", attends to a basic concept in legal analysis and judicial responsibility. At its core, this declaration emphasizes the function of the judiciary within the structure of separation of powers, a doctrine main to many democratic systems.
John Paul Stevens, as a U.S. Supreme Court Justice, was entrusted with translating and applying existing laws. This quote recommends that judges must avoid serving as legislators by applying nonexistent laws or creating laws from the bench. Rather, their duty is to analyze existing statutes and constitutional provisions as composed, making sure that current laws are applied accurately and relatively.
The quote can be seen as a support of judicial restraint, an approach where judges limit their own power by adhering closely to the text of the law and delaying more significant policy making to chosen lawmakers. This approach respects the boundaries between legal and judicial roles, avoiding judges from violating their authority by crafting new policies or legal standards in lieu of composed legislation.
Furthermore, this viewpoint verifies the importance of legal intent and the democratic procedure. Laws are developed through a democratic process involving argument, settlement, and ballot. By sticking to existing laws, judges show respect for the democratic mechanisms and the representatives chosen to create laws.
Stevens' declaration can also be a caution versus judicial advocacy, where judges might enforce their personal views or viewed societal needs through their judgments. By promoting the idea that it is not the judiciary's location to use unwritten laws, Stevens underscores the need for judiciary adherence to the guideline of law and security against arbitrary decision-making.
In summary, this quote reflects the crucial balance of power and responsibility within a democratic society, where the judiciary upholds existing laws while acknowledging the legislature's function in drafting and enacting brand-new laws. It champs the concept of separation of powers and highlights the judiciary's important role in maintaining the integrity of the legal system.
About the Author