"Marriages are under strain today in terms of economics. There are social cross-currents. We see failed marriages. But it is not under attack by our gay and lesbian citizens"
About this Quote
Earl Blumenauer reframes a polarizing debate by distinguishing strain from attack. He acknowledges that many marriages struggle, but he locates the source in material pressures and shifting social patterns, not in the aspirations of gay and lesbian couples. The move is both analytical and moral: it resists scapegoating a minority and demands attention to the conditions that actually erode family stability.
Economics looms largest in the diagnosis. Stagnant wages, precarious work, long hours, caregiving burdens, healthcare and housing costs, and the absence of robust family policies create chronic stress that can hollow out relationships. Couples postpone marriage, argue over money, and struggle to balance childrearing with work because the arithmetic is brutal, not because someone else down the street seeks a marriage license. Calling this a cultural war lets lawmakers off the hook for policy failures that make partnership harder than it needs to be.
Social cross-currents capture the complexity of modern life: evolving gender roles, mobility that scatters kin networks, higher expectations for emotional fulfillment, and shifting norms around divorce and cohabitation. These currents do not amount to an assault; they are the water in which people now swim. Recognizing them invites adaptation and support, not panic.
Against claims that marriage equality would harm the institution, the final line turns the logic on its head. Gay and lesbian citizens pressing for the right to marry signal allegiance to the institution’s responsibilities and protections. Their inclusion does not diminish heterosexual marriages; it affirms a shared civic framework. Experience in jurisdictions that recognized same-sex marriage bore this out: no collapse of heterosexual marriage followed, and many families gained legal stability.
Blumenauer’s intervention, delivered amid heated early-2000s fights over marriage laws, redirects energy from symbolic battles to pragmatic reform. If marriage is under strain, the remedy is not exclusion but investment: economic security, family leave, childcare, and social supports that help all couples keep their promises.
Economics looms largest in the diagnosis. Stagnant wages, precarious work, long hours, caregiving burdens, healthcare and housing costs, and the absence of robust family policies create chronic stress that can hollow out relationships. Couples postpone marriage, argue over money, and struggle to balance childrearing with work because the arithmetic is brutal, not because someone else down the street seeks a marriage license. Calling this a cultural war lets lawmakers off the hook for policy failures that make partnership harder than it needs to be.
Social cross-currents capture the complexity of modern life: evolving gender roles, mobility that scatters kin networks, higher expectations for emotional fulfillment, and shifting norms around divorce and cohabitation. These currents do not amount to an assault; they are the water in which people now swim. Recognizing them invites adaptation and support, not panic.
Against claims that marriage equality would harm the institution, the final line turns the logic on its head. Gay and lesbian citizens pressing for the right to marry signal allegiance to the institution’s responsibilities and protections. Their inclusion does not diminish heterosexual marriages; it affirms a shared civic framework. Experience in jurisdictions that recognized same-sex marriage bore this out: no collapse of heterosexual marriage followed, and many families gained legal stability.
Blumenauer’s intervention, delivered amid heated early-2000s fights over marriage laws, redirects energy from symbolic battles to pragmatic reform. If marriage is under strain, the remedy is not exclusion but investment: economic security, family leave, childcare, and social supports that help all couples keep their promises.
Quote Details
| Topic | Marriage |
|---|
More Quotes by Earl
Add to List
