"No rule is so general, which admits not some exception"
About this Quote
Certainty has always been a seductive shortcut, and Burton punctures it with a scholar’s dry needle: “No rule is so general, which admits not some exception.” The line works because it sounds like a rule while quietly sabotaging the very idea of rule-making. Its syntax is almost self-parodying - “so general” pushed to the brink, then undercut by “some exception,” a small phrase that collapses grand systems with the lightest touch.
Burton, best known for The Anatomy of Melancholy, wrote in an era obsessed with cataloging: humors, habits, vices, virtues, the natural world. Early modern learning loved taxonomies; it also lived amid upheaval - religious conflict, expanding travel, new science jostling old authorities. Burton’s intent isn’t to abandon principles but to warn against the arrogance of totalizing ones. He’s speaking to readers who want neat moral prescriptions, medical certainties, and social laws that behave like geometry. Instead, he offers a more clinical realism: people and life refuse to stay inside the boxes we build.
The subtext is a critique of dogmatism disguised as common sense. By framing the thought as a maxim, Burton gives it authority; by insisting every maxim leaks, he trains the reader in skepticism without sounding revolutionary. It’s humility posed as logic. And it’s also a sly permission slip: if exceptions always exist, then judgment requires attention, not just adherence. The line anticipates modern discomfort with one-size-fits-all policies and hot-take absolutes, reminding us that what feels “general” is often just what we’ve stopped examining.
Burton, best known for The Anatomy of Melancholy, wrote in an era obsessed with cataloging: humors, habits, vices, virtues, the natural world. Early modern learning loved taxonomies; it also lived amid upheaval - religious conflict, expanding travel, new science jostling old authorities. Burton’s intent isn’t to abandon principles but to warn against the arrogance of totalizing ones. He’s speaking to readers who want neat moral prescriptions, medical certainties, and social laws that behave like geometry. Instead, he offers a more clinical realism: people and life refuse to stay inside the boxes we build.
The subtext is a critique of dogmatism disguised as common sense. By framing the thought as a maxim, Burton gives it authority; by insisting every maxim leaks, he trains the reader in skepticism without sounding revolutionary. It’s humility posed as logic. And it’s also a sly permission slip: if exceptions always exist, then judgment requires attention, not just adherence. The line anticipates modern discomfort with one-size-fits-all policies and hot-take absolutes, reminding us that what feels “general” is often just what we’ve stopped examining.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
