"No rules exist, and examples are simply life-savers answering the appeals of rules making vain attempts to exist"
About this Quote
Andre Breton’s statement challenges the conventional foundations of structure and meaning, especially as applied to creativity and human experience. Traditionally, rules are perceived as frameworks that provide order and clarity, guiding actions, art, and even thought. Breton, however, dismisses the genuine existence of rules, implying that the chaos and unpredictability of existence outpace any attempt at codification or standardization.
He suggests that what are perceived as rules are, in reality, human inventions, constructed only after the event, in a retrospective effort to make sense of an unruly reality. Examples, in this context, become the lifeboats in a sea of uncertainty. They are concrete instances, lived or observed, that help individuals navigate when theoretical rules fail to offer guidance. Rather than supporting the authority of rules, examples expose their inadequacies, each exception and lived reality highlighting the insufficiency and artificiality of prescribed patterns.
Rules “making vain attempts to exist” captures the futility inherent in trying to contain the multiplicity of experience within set boundaries. Life resists total description and neat compartmentalization; its richness, spontaneity, and irrationality evade formulaic expression. Artistic creation, in particular, thrives in this freedom, refusing to be bound by preconceived templates or doctrinal direction. Breton, as a leading figure in surrealism, advocates for the liberation of the mind and art from predetermined rules, embracing unconscious impulses and the unforeseen.
Ultimately, Breton elevates the particular, the experiential, and the singular over the abstract and universal. Rather than being governed by rules, individuals respond to unique situations and are rescued by concrete examples when the insufficiency of abstract regulations becomes obvious. This perspective encourages a dynamic and open-ended engagement with life, where adaptability and direct experience supersede rigid conformity.
He suggests that what are perceived as rules are, in reality, human inventions, constructed only after the event, in a retrospective effort to make sense of an unruly reality. Examples, in this context, become the lifeboats in a sea of uncertainty. They are concrete instances, lived or observed, that help individuals navigate when theoretical rules fail to offer guidance. Rather than supporting the authority of rules, examples expose their inadequacies, each exception and lived reality highlighting the insufficiency and artificiality of prescribed patterns.
Rules “making vain attempts to exist” captures the futility inherent in trying to contain the multiplicity of experience within set boundaries. Life resists total description and neat compartmentalization; its richness, spontaneity, and irrationality evade formulaic expression. Artistic creation, in particular, thrives in this freedom, refusing to be bound by preconceived templates or doctrinal direction. Breton, as a leading figure in surrealism, advocates for the liberation of the mind and art from predetermined rules, embracing unconscious impulses and the unforeseen.
Ultimately, Breton elevates the particular, the experiential, and the singular over the abstract and universal. Rather than being governed by rules, individuals respond to unique situations and are rescued by concrete examples when the insufficiency of abstract regulations becomes obvious. This perspective encourages a dynamic and open-ended engagement with life, where adaptability and direct experience supersede rigid conformity.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|
More Quotes by Andre
Add to List
