"Life is like music, it must be composed by ear, feeling and instinct, not by rule. Nevertheless one had better know the rules, for they sometimes guide in doubtful cases, though not often"
About this Quote
Paracelsus is staging a quiet mutiny against the era’s worship of inherited authority. In the early 1500s, “rule” meant more than technique; it meant scholastic medicine, Aristotle-by-rote, the comforting idea that truth arrives prepackaged in approved texts. His music metaphor slips a blade between those pages. Composition happens “by ear, feeling and instinct” because real knowledge, in his view, is made in contact with the world: the bedside, the laboratory, the stubborn fact that bodies don’t behave like syllogisms.
The line works because it flatters intuition without turning it into anti-intellectualism. He doesn’t romanticize ignorance; he insists on craft. “Nevertheless one had better know the rules” is not a retreat, it’s a power move: I can break rules precisely because I understand them. Rules are demoted from sovereign law to emergency tool, “sometimes” helpful in “doubtful cases,” and the parenthetical “though not often” lands like a dry cough. That last clause is the subtextual punch: if you find yourself leaning on rules frequently, you’re not practicing science, you’re practicing compliance.
Context matters: Paracelsus was notorious for challenging medical orthodoxy and elevating experience over citation. Read this way, the quote isn’t about art versus science; it’s a manifesto for a more experimental science, one that treats theory as a score and reality as performance. The authority shifts from the library to the senses, from credentialed tradition to tested insight.
The line works because it flatters intuition without turning it into anti-intellectualism. He doesn’t romanticize ignorance; he insists on craft. “Nevertheless one had better know the rules” is not a retreat, it’s a power move: I can break rules precisely because I understand them. Rules are demoted from sovereign law to emergency tool, “sometimes” helpful in “doubtful cases,” and the parenthetical “though not often” lands like a dry cough. That last clause is the subtextual punch: if you find yourself leaning on rules frequently, you’re not practicing science, you’re practicing compliance.
Context matters: Paracelsus was notorious for challenging medical orthodoxy and elevating experience over citation. Read this way, the quote isn’t about art versus science; it’s a manifesto for a more experimental science, one that treats theory as a score and reality as performance. The authority shifts from the library to the senses, from credentialed tradition to tested insight.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Philipus
Add to List
