"Not only our future economic soundness but the very soundness of our democratic institutions depends on the determination of our government to give employment to idle men"
About this Quote
Roosevelt frames employment as more than a bread-and-butter issue; he sells it as democracy’s immune system. The line’s force comes from its double escalation: “not only” economic stability, “but the very soundness” of democratic institutions. In one move, joblessness stops being a private misfortune or a market hiccup and becomes a public threat with constitutional implications. It’s classic FDR: a moral argument dressed in the crisp suit of institutional self-preservation.
The specific intent is to legitimize aggressive federal action in a political culture that still treated “relief” as a suspect word. By insisting the government must “give employment,” Roosevelt sidesteps the stigma of the dole. Work is positioned as a civic bond, not charity. That phrasing also quietly expands the state’s job description: if democracy depends on employment, then the federal government isn’t merely allowed to intervene in the economy; it’s obligated to.
The subtext is sharper. “Idle men” isn’t a neutral description; it’s a warning label. Mass idleness breeds desperation, and desperation breeds demagogues. Roosevelt is speaking in the shadow of the Great Depression and the global 1930s, when authoritarian movements were converting economic collapse into political capture. The message to skeptics is implicit: refuse job programs and you don’t just risk slower growth; you risk a citizenry unmoored from the promises that make ballots feel meaningful.
Context matters: New Deal politics required turning emergency policy into a durable philosophy. This sentence is a bridge between crisis management and a new social contract, where economic rights are recast as democratic infrastructure.
The specific intent is to legitimize aggressive federal action in a political culture that still treated “relief” as a suspect word. By insisting the government must “give employment,” Roosevelt sidesteps the stigma of the dole. Work is positioned as a civic bond, not charity. That phrasing also quietly expands the state’s job description: if democracy depends on employment, then the federal government isn’t merely allowed to intervene in the economy; it’s obligated to.
The subtext is sharper. “Idle men” isn’t a neutral description; it’s a warning label. Mass idleness breeds desperation, and desperation breeds demagogues. Roosevelt is speaking in the shadow of the Great Depression and the global 1930s, when authoritarian movements were converting economic collapse into political capture. The message to skeptics is implicit: refuse job programs and you don’t just risk slower growth; you risk a citizenry unmoored from the promises that make ballots feel meaningful.
Context matters: New Deal politics required turning emergency policy into a durable philosophy. This sentence is a bridge between crisis management and a new social contract, where economic rights are recast as democratic infrastructure.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by Franklin
Add to List





