"Pythagoras took the next important step by subordinating the mere matter of nature to its essential principle of form and order, identifying the latter with reason or the soul"
About this Quote
Pythagoras shows up here less as a beard-stroking mystic than as a cultural turning point: the moment “nature” gets demoted from brute substance to something legible, even judgeable, by pattern. Baldwin’s phrasing is doing quiet but heavy lifting. “Subordinating” is a power word. Matter isn’t denied; it’s put in its place, made secondary to “form and order.” That hierarchy telegraphs a modern psychological ambition: if mind can be aligned with structure, then mind can claim authority over the mess of sensation.
The sly move is the identification of form with “reason or the soul.” Baldwin is pointing to an ancient merger that still haunts modern thought: the idea that the world’s deep order and the self’s inner order are the same kind of thing. It’s not just that numbers describe reality; it’s that rationality becomes quasi-spiritual, the soul recast as an organizing principle rather than a religious deposit. That’s an upgrade in status for cognition, and it’s also a cultural seduction: if the cosmos is intelligible, then the person who can read its code gets to speak with something like moral or metaphysical legitimacy.
Context matters: writing as a psychologist in an era enamored of scientific system-building, Baldwin is retrofitting Pythagoras as a patron saint of “mind as organizer.” The subtext is a defense of psychology’s scope. If form and order are primary, then studying perception, reasoning, and the “soul” isn’t soft speculation; it’s an inquiry into the very principle that makes nature more than noise.
The sly move is the identification of form with “reason or the soul.” Baldwin is pointing to an ancient merger that still haunts modern thought: the idea that the world’s deep order and the self’s inner order are the same kind of thing. It’s not just that numbers describe reality; it’s that rationality becomes quasi-spiritual, the soul recast as an organizing principle rather than a religious deposit. That’s an upgrade in status for cognition, and it’s also a cultural seduction: if the cosmos is intelligible, then the person who can read its code gets to speak with something like moral or metaphysical legitimacy.
Context matters: writing as a psychologist in an era enamored of scientific system-building, Baldwin is retrofitting Pythagoras as a patron saint of “mind as organizer.” The subtext is a defense of psychology’s scope. If form and order are primary, then studying perception, reasoning, and the “soul” isn’t soft speculation; it’s an inquiry into the very principle that makes nature more than noise.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by James
Add to List
