"The difference of the degrees in which the individuals of a great community enjoy the good things of life has been a theme of declaration and discontent in all ages"
About this Quote
Herschel, the astronomer who found new planets by training his eye on faint light, turns that same instrument on society: inequality is not a scandal of one era but a repeating pattern, as constant as the night sky. The line’s force comes from its cool, almost clinical phrasing. “Difference of the degrees” sounds like measurement, not outrage. By refusing to moralize outright, he smuggles in a sharper point: disparity isn’t an anomaly that polite reforms will simply erase; it’s a structural feature of “a great community,” the very kind that congratulates itself on progress.
The phrase “good things of life” is deliberately vague, a rhetorical sleight of hand that lets readers supply their own inventory: wealth, leisure, education, safety, dignity. That ambiguity widens the quote’s target. Herschel isn’t only talking about income; he’s mapping how societies distribute comfort and agency. “Declaration and discontent” sketches a cycle: elites justify the gradient, the disadvantaged contest it, and history keeps replaying the argument with new costumes.
Context matters. Herschel lived through the Industrial Revolution’s early shocks, Britain’s expanding empire, and the ideological aftershocks of the American and French revolutions, when “declaration” was a literal genre and “discontent” a political force. His sentence reads like an attempt to de-dramatize revolutionary fever without denying the grievance. It’s a scientist’s warning: the data set is long, the trendline persistent, and anyone promising a final fix is probably selling mythology.
The phrase “good things of life” is deliberately vague, a rhetorical sleight of hand that lets readers supply their own inventory: wealth, leisure, education, safety, dignity. That ambiguity widens the quote’s target. Herschel isn’t only talking about income; he’s mapping how societies distribute comfort and agency. “Declaration and discontent” sketches a cycle: elites justify the gradient, the disadvantaged contest it, and history keeps replaying the argument with new costumes.
Context matters. Herschel lived through the Industrial Revolution’s early shocks, Britain’s expanding empire, and the ideological aftershocks of the American and French revolutions, when “declaration” was a literal genre and “discontent” a political force. His sentence reads like an attempt to de-dramatize revolutionary fever without denying the grievance. It’s a scientist’s warning: the data set is long, the trendline persistent, and anyone promising a final fix is probably selling mythology.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by William
Add to List








