"The enemy is within the gates; it is with our own luxury, our own folly, our own criminality that we have to contend"
About this Quote
Cicero’s line lands like a slap precisely because it refuses the comforting script of external menace. “Within the gates” is not just metaphor; it’s a Roman image of breached walls, the sacred boundary between civic order and chaos. He hijacks that wartime language to indict something more embarrassing than invasion: self-inflicted decline. The sentence is built to corner the listener. If the enemy is “within,” there’s no heroic frontier to ride to, no foreign villain to scapegoat, only the hard work of restraint and reform.
The subtext is class-coded and political. “Luxury” isn’t a private vice in late-republic Rome; it’s a public symptom of elite decay, the softening that follows empire’s spoils. “Folly” widens the charge from moral weakness to collective stupidity: bad judgment, unserious leaders, citizens seduced by spectacle. Then Cicero sharpens the knife with “criminality,” collapsing the gap between corruption and crime. He’s telling his audience that what they tolerate as normal politics is already lawlessness, and that the republic is being dismantled not by barbarians but by insiders who’ve learned to monetize the state.
Context matters: Cicero is speaking from a republic in crisis, where factional violence, bribery, and strongmen were eroding institutions from the inside out. The rhetorical strategy is classic civic moralism, but it’s also a political move: redefine the real threat so urgency attaches to reform, not conquest. It works because it weaponizes shame. Rome’s pride was security and discipline; Cicero makes indulgence sound like treason.
The subtext is class-coded and political. “Luxury” isn’t a private vice in late-republic Rome; it’s a public symptom of elite decay, the softening that follows empire’s spoils. “Folly” widens the charge from moral weakness to collective stupidity: bad judgment, unserious leaders, citizens seduced by spectacle. Then Cicero sharpens the knife with “criminality,” collapsing the gap between corruption and crime. He’s telling his audience that what they tolerate as normal politics is already lawlessness, and that the republic is being dismantled not by barbarians but by insiders who’ve learned to monetize the state.
Context matters: Cicero is speaking from a republic in crisis, where factional violence, bribery, and strongmen were eroding institutions from the inside out. The rhetorical strategy is classic civic moralism, but it’s also a political move: redefine the real threat so urgency attaches to reform, not conquest. It works because it weaponizes shame. Rome’s pride was security and discipline; Cicero makes indulgence sound like treason.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|---|
| Source | Unverified source: In Catilinam (Second Catilinarian Oration), §11 (Cicero, -63)
Evidence: Oration 2, ch. 5, §11 (2.5.11). This wording is a modern English translation of Cicero’s Second Catilinarian Oration (In Catilinam II), specifically §11, whose Latin includes: “inclusum periculum est, intus est hostis. cum luxuria nobis, cum amentia, cum scelere certandum est.” The frequently-cir... Other candidates (2) The Gilligan Principle (The Problem with Darwinism) (Steve Lee, 2013) compilation95.7% ... Cicero. "The enemy is within the gates; it is with our own luxury, our own folly, our own criminality that we hav... Cicero (Cicero) compilation35.7% death the sensation is either pleasant or there is none at all but this should be thought on from our youth up so tha... |
More Quotes by Cicero
Add to List








