"There are some things the general public does not need to know and shouldn't. I believe democracy flourishes when the government can take legitimate steps to keep its secrets, and when the press can decide whether to print what it knows"
- Katherine Graham
About this Quote
Katherine Graham's quote offers a nuanced point of view on the balancing act between government openness and secrecy, as well as the crucial role of journalism in a democracy. At its core, the declaration highlights the intricate interplay between the need for federal government confidentiality and the significance of press liberty.
The first part of her statement, "There are some things the general public does not require to know and shouldn't," suggests that there are specific matters within government operations that are better kept from public disclosure. These may consist of sensitive national security details, information about diplomatic settlements, or intelligence techniques that, if exposed, might jeopardize a nation's safety or international relations. Graham is acknowledging that total openness could, in many cases, be harmful rather than helpful to public welfare.
The expression "democracy flourishes when the federal government can take genuine actions to keep its secrets" suggests that a functioning democracy does not need overall openness. Instead, it can thrive when the federal government can sensibly safeguard specific elements of its operations. The keyword here is "genuine," highlighting that any secrecy should have a legitimate, ethical basis and not be used to cover up misdeed or corruption. This highlights the requirement for a framework within federal government institutions to identify what qualifies as legally sensitive info.
The latter part of Graham's quote, "when journalism can decide whether to print what it understands," talks to the essential watchdog role of the media. Journalism acts as a counterbalance to government power and secrecy, holding it accountable to the public. Graham rely on the press's judgment to evaluate what info remains in the public interest and benefits exposure. This reflects the symbiotic relationship in between the federal government and journalism, where both entities need to exercise their duties with stability and discernment.
In essence, Graham's quote presents a vision of democracy that flourishes on both accountable federal government secrecy and an independent, cautious press-- each respecting the other's function and working together to serve the public interest.
"The one pervading evil of democracy is the tyranny of the majority, or rather of that party, not always the majority, that succeeds, by force or fraud, in carrying elections"