"What we call real estate - the solid ground to build a house on - is the broad foundation on which nearly all the guilt of this world rests"
About this Quote
Hawthorne takes something as plain as dirt and turns it into an indictment. Real estate, usually treated as the most practical of assets, becomes in his hands the moral stage on which people justify, conceal, and inherit wrongdoing. The sly brilliance is the way he smuggles accusation into a definition: “the solid ground to build a house on” sounds like a brochure line, then the sentence swivels and makes that solidity feel complicit. Land isn’t just property; it’s permanence. And permanence is exactly what lets guilt stick.
The subtext is Puritan New England, where Hawthorne grew up under the long shadow of public righteousness and private transgression (his own family’s ties to the Salem witch trials haunt his work). In that world, the house is never merely shelter. It’s reputation made visible, a monument to a lineage, a claim that your story is stable and legitimate. Owning land lets you literalize innocence: you put down roots, you build, you name, you bequeath. Hawthorne’s point is that this solidity often rests on softer, uglier material - dispossession, exploitation, inherited privilege, the quiet cruelty required to keep certain people “in their place.”
He’s also needling a specifically American faith that property equals virtue. If guilt can be abstracted, moral responsibility can be too: blame gets buried under deeds and fences, converted into something “settled.” Hawthorne doesn’t argue that every homeowner is evil; he suggests the system of claiming ground, and calling it rightful, is one of the world’s most efficient ways to launder sin into stability.
The subtext is Puritan New England, where Hawthorne grew up under the long shadow of public righteousness and private transgression (his own family’s ties to the Salem witch trials haunt his work). In that world, the house is never merely shelter. It’s reputation made visible, a monument to a lineage, a claim that your story is stable and legitimate. Owning land lets you literalize innocence: you put down roots, you build, you name, you bequeath. Hawthorne’s point is that this solidity often rests on softer, uglier material - dispossession, exploitation, inherited privilege, the quiet cruelty required to keep certain people “in their place.”
He’s also needling a specifically American faith that property equals virtue. If guilt can be abstracted, moral responsibility can be too: blame gets buried under deeds and fences, converted into something “settled.” Hawthorne doesn’t argue that every homeowner is evil; he suggests the system of claiming ground, and calling it rightful, is one of the world’s most efficient ways to launder sin into stability.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Nathaniel
Add to List






