"You lose your manners when you are poor"
About this Quote
"You lose your manners when you are poor" distills the hard bargain poverty extracts: civility is a luxury secured by stability. Manners are often less about innate virtue than about surplus time, money, and safety to cushion frustration and delay desire. When those buffers disappear, need speaks louder than etiquette. Hellman understood how class churns the soul: her Southern dramas show elegant rooms where refined gestures mask cruelty, while the people pressed to the margins are scolded for any breach of decorum even as they struggle to eat. The line is both descriptive and accusatory. It observes that hunger frays patience, and it condemns a social order that makes grace contingent on cash.
To lose manners in this sense is to lose the performance that keeps the powerful comfortable. Poverty forces directness. It makes one ask, insist, refuse, trespass, take risks that respectability forbids. That loss is not moral decline; it is triage. Hellman exposes the hypocrisy by which the wealthy commit injuries behind polite smiles, while the poor are punished for the smallest impoliteness. Manners become a currency of class, a code policed to keep people in their place.
At the same time, the line hints at sadness. People want dignity, and politesse can be a fragile shield for self-respect. Poverty strips even that, compelling gestures that later shame the person who had to make them. The pathos of Hellman's characters lies in that trap: decorum costs money they do not have, truth costs favor they cannot afford to lose. She writes with the clarity of the Depression era and the Jim Crow South, where survival contradicted gentility. What remains is an ethical challenge: judge less by etiquette, more by conditions; notice who pays for civility, and who profits from it.
To lose manners in this sense is to lose the performance that keeps the powerful comfortable. Poverty forces directness. It makes one ask, insist, refuse, trespass, take risks that respectability forbids. That loss is not moral decline; it is triage. Hellman exposes the hypocrisy by which the wealthy commit injuries behind polite smiles, while the poor are punished for the smallest impoliteness. Manners become a currency of class, a code policed to keep people in their place.
At the same time, the line hints at sadness. People want dignity, and politesse can be a fragile shield for self-respect. Poverty strips even that, compelling gestures that later shame the person who had to make them. The pathos of Hellman's characters lies in that trap: decorum costs money they do not have, truth costs favor they cannot afford to lose. She writes with the clarity of the Depression era and the Jim Crow South, where survival contradicted gentility. What remains is an ethical challenge: judge less by etiquette, more by conditions; notice who pays for civility, and who profits from it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Money |
|---|
More Quotes by Lillian
Add to List
