"Your memory is a monster; you forget - it doesn't. It simply files things away. It keeps things for you, or hides things from you - and summons them to your recall with a will of its own. You think you have a memory; but it has you!"
About this Quote
Irving’s genius here is the flip: memory isn’t a cozy scrapbook, it’s an animal with appetite and autonomy. By calling it a monster, he refuses the polite, therapeutic idea that remembering is something you manage with enough willpower and the right narrative. The syntax stalks forward in short, blunt clauses - “you forget - it doesn’t” - like a finger jabbed into the reader’s chest. Then the metaphor turns bureaucratic: memory “files things away.” That shift matters. Monsters are supposed to be chaotic; filing is cold, procedural, almost corporate. Irving’s point is that the most terrifying part of memory isn’t its drama, it’s its orderliness. It keeps receipts.
The subtext is trauma without the diagnostic label. “Hides things from you” nods to repression and self-protection, but Irving won’t romanticize it as healing. What’s hidden isn’t gone; it’s archived, waiting for a trigger to “summon” it back. That verb is slyly supernatural: recall isn’t retrieval, it’s invocation. You don’t open a drawer; you wake something.
Contextually, this tracks with Irving’s recurring preoccupations: bodies marked by accident, lives reshaped by events that don’t stay in the past just because time moves on. The final line lands because it’s both witty and bleakly accurate: the modern self loves to imagine itself as an owner-operator, curating experience into identity. Irving insists the curator is also the captive. Memory isn’t your tool; it’s the thing that quietly decides when you’re allowed to be free.
The subtext is trauma without the diagnostic label. “Hides things from you” nods to repression and self-protection, but Irving won’t romanticize it as healing. What’s hidden isn’t gone; it’s archived, waiting for a trigger to “summon” it back. That verb is slyly supernatural: recall isn’t retrieval, it’s invocation. You don’t open a drawer; you wake something.
Contextually, this tracks with Irving’s recurring preoccupations: bodies marked by accident, lives reshaped by events that don’t stay in the past just because time moves on. The final line lands because it’s both witty and bleakly accurate: the modern self loves to imagine itself as an owner-operator, curating experience into identity. Irving insists the curator is also the captive. Memory isn’t your tool; it’s the thing that quietly decides when you’re allowed to be free.
Quote Details
| Topic | Nostalgia |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List







