Skip to main content

Daily Inspiration Quote by Pythagoras

"As soon as laws are necessary for men, they are no longer fit for freedom"

About this Quote

Freedom, in Pythagoras's formulation, is less a right than a diagnostic. The moment a society needs laws to keep people from stealing, lying, or brutalizing each other, something more foundational has already failed: the internal discipline that makes external coercion redundant. It is a severe, almost austere standard. Not "laws can be abused", but "laws are an admission of moral collapse."

Coming from a mathematician-philosopher associated with a rule-bound community, the line carries a productive tension. Pythagorean life reportedly ran on strict codes, ritual, and hierarchy. That makes the aphorism read less like hippie libertarianism and more like an elite critique of the masses: the truly free person is self-governing, calibrated by reason and harmony; everyone else requires scaffolding. Laws become a blunt instrument for those who cannot hold their own lives in proportion.

The subtext is also political. In the Greek world of city-states, "freedom" didn't mean maximal personal expression; it meant the capacity to participate in civic life without being ruled like a child or a slave. Needing laws suggests citizens have reverted to impulse, faction, and appetite - conditions that invite tyranny as surely as they invite regulation. The quote works because it flips our modern assumption: that laws create freedom. Pythagoras treats them as a symptom, not a solution, and in doing so turns freedom into a moral achievement rather than a legal status.

Quote Details

TopicFreedom
Source
Later attribution: Pythagoras (Pythagoras) modern compilation
Text match: 98.33%   Provider: Wikiquote
Evidence:
ray vol v as soon as laws are necessary for men they are no longer fit for freedom as quot
Other candidates (1)
Google Books compilation95.0%
... Pythagoras ; called by Dr. Arnold " the Devil's favorite text . " As soon as laws are necessary for men , they ar...
More Quotes by Pythagoras Add to List
As Soon as Laws Are Necessary for Men, Freedom is Lost
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

Pythagoras

Pythagoras (570 BC - 495 BC) was a Mathematician from Greece.

23 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

Ralph Waldo Emerson, Philosopher
Ralph Waldo Emerson