"As soon as laws are necessary for men, they are no longer fit for freedom"
About this Quote
Freedom, in Pythagoras's formulation, is less a right than a diagnostic. The moment a society needs laws to keep people from stealing, lying, or brutalizing each other, something more foundational has already failed: the internal discipline that makes external coercion redundant. It is a severe, almost austere standard. Not "laws can be abused", but "laws are an admission of moral collapse."
Coming from a mathematician-philosopher associated with a rule-bound community, the line carries a productive tension. Pythagorean life reportedly ran on strict codes, ritual, and hierarchy. That makes the aphorism read less like hippie libertarianism and more like an elite critique of the masses: the truly free person is self-governing, calibrated by reason and harmony; everyone else requires scaffolding. Laws become a blunt instrument for those who cannot hold their own lives in proportion.
The subtext is also political. In the Greek world of city-states, "freedom" didn't mean maximal personal expression; it meant the capacity to participate in civic life without being ruled like a child or a slave. Needing laws suggests citizens have reverted to impulse, faction, and appetite - conditions that invite tyranny as surely as they invite regulation. The quote works because it flips our modern assumption: that laws create freedom. Pythagoras treats them as a symptom, not a solution, and in doing so turns freedom into a moral achievement rather than a legal status.
Coming from a mathematician-philosopher associated with a rule-bound community, the line carries a productive tension. Pythagorean life reportedly ran on strict codes, ritual, and hierarchy. That makes the aphorism read less like hippie libertarianism and more like an elite critique of the masses: the truly free person is self-governing, calibrated by reason and harmony; everyone else requires scaffolding. Laws become a blunt instrument for those who cannot hold their own lives in proportion.
The subtext is also political. In the Greek world of city-states, "freedom" didn't mean maximal personal expression; it meant the capacity to participate in civic life without being ruled like a child or a slave. Needing laws suggests citizens have reverted to impulse, faction, and appetite - conditions that invite tyranny as surely as they invite regulation. The quote works because it flips our modern assumption: that laws create freedom. Pythagoras treats them as a symptom, not a solution, and in doing so turns freedom into a moral achievement rather than a legal status.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: Pythagoras (Pythagoras) modern compilation
Evidence: ray vol v as soon as laws are necessary for men they are no longer fit for freedom as quot Other candidates (1) Google Books compilation95.0% ... Pythagoras ; called by Dr. Arnold " the Devil's favorite text . " As soon as laws are necessary for men , they ar... |
More Quotes by Pythagoras
Add to List









