"But I do believe this - I believe that fundamentally, society is headed in the right direction or wants to head in the right direction, and I think judges have an obligation to try to help it head there"
About this Quote
Mills Lane talks like a referee because that is what he became in the public mind: the guy who keeps the fight from turning into a riot. The line is optimistic, but it is a very particular, procedural kind of optimism. He is not praising society as it is; he is betting on its trajectory. That bet lets him frame judging less as cold arbitration and more as civic choreography: the bench as a steady hand on the steering wheel when the road gets slick.
The subtext is a gentle redefinition of neutrality. Judges are supposed to call balls and strikes, not decide where the game should go. Lane slips a directional claim into the job description: if society "wants" to improve, the judge should "help it head there". That word choice matters. "Wants" suggests a collective moral instinct, a rough consensus bubbling under the noise. "Help" sounds modest, almost humble, yet it smuggles in power - the authority to interpret what "the right direction" is, and to nudge outcomes accordingly.
Contextually, coming from a celebrity judge, it reads like a defense of a persona and a platform. Television turned judging into a kind of moral entertainment, where fairness has to be legible in real time and justice needs a story arc. Lane is trying to reconcile popular legitimacy with legal legitimacy: if people lose faith in institutions, a judge cannot just be correct; he has to be seen as steering away from chaos. The risk, of course, is that "headed in the right direction" becomes whatever the loudest crowd is chanting outside the courthouse.
The subtext is a gentle redefinition of neutrality. Judges are supposed to call balls and strikes, not decide where the game should go. Lane slips a directional claim into the job description: if society "wants" to improve, the judge should "help it head there". That word choice matters. "Wants" suggests a collective moral instinct, a rough consensus bubbling under the noise. "Help" sounds modest, almost humble, yet it smuggles in power - the authority to interpret what "the right direction" is, and to nudge outcomes accordingly.
Contextually, coming from a celebrity judge, it reads like a defense of a persona and a platform. Television turned judging into a kind of moral entertainment, where fairness has to be legible in real time and justice needs a story arc. Lane is trying to reconcile popular legitimacy with legal legitimacy: if people lose faith in institutions, a judge cannot just be correct; he has to be seen as steering away from chaos. The risk, of course, is that "headed in the right direction" becomes whatever the loudest crowd is chanting outside the courthouse.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Judge
Add to List






