"If you understood everything I say, you'd be me!"
About this Quote
Miles Davis isn’t offering a cute riddle here; he’s drawing a hard border around experience. “If you understood everything I say, you’d be me!” turns the usual demand on artists - explain yourself, clarify your meaning, translate your choices - into a refusal with teeth. The line is funny because it’s bluntly impossible. It’s also a flex: the point of Miles isn’t that he can be decoded, it’s that he can’t.
The intent is protection and provocation at once. Davis spent his career being asked to narrate his own genius in plain English, especially as jazz got treated like an “art” that needed scholarly footnotes or polite packaging. He answers by insisting that full comprehension would require the totality of his life: the racial and industry pressures, the competitiveness of the bandstand, the private irritations, the relentless discipline, the ear trained by nights that didn’t end at midnight. Language can gesture at that; it can’t reproduce it.
Subtextually, it’s also a manifesto for modern jazz itself. Miles’s music - cool minimalism, modal openness, electric rupture - often operates by withholding: space, silence, the note not played. Listeners trained on certainty want a key. He’s saying the key is the lock: the gap between what you want explained and what can be transmitted is where the art lives.
There’s ego here, sure, but it’s strategic ego. Davis makes identity the final unshareable instrument, daring you to stop chasing translation and start listening on his terms.
The intent is protection and provocation at once. Davis spent his career being asked to narrate his own genius in plain English, especially as jazz got treated like an “art” that needed scholarly footnotes or polite packaging. He answers by insisting that full comprehension would require the totality of his life: the racial and industry pressures, the competitiveness of the bandstand, the private irritations, the relentless discipline, the ear trained by nights that didn’t end at midnight. Language can gesture at that; it can’t reproduce it.
Subtextually, it’s also a manifesto for modern jazz itself. Miles’s music - cool minimalism, modal openness, electric rupture - often operates by withholding: space, silence, the note not played. Listeners trained on certainty want a key. He’s saying the key is the lock: the gap between what you want explained and what can be transmitted is where the art lives.
There’s ego here, sure, but it’s strategic ego. Davis makes identity the final unshareable instrument, daring you to stop chasing translation and start listening on his terms.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: Inside Transracial Adoption (Gail Steinberg, Beth Hall, 2012) modern compilationISBN: 9780857006424 · ID: KlvImFslKlsC
Evidence: ... If you understood everything I say, you'd be me.” —Miles Davis Children often make assumptions based on limited information. In early childhood some children think: • All brown people are adopted. • All Chinese females are adopted ... Other candidates (1) Miles Davis (Miles Davis) compilation35.0% from the slum of my girlhood and yet overlapping with it miles would be miles ci |
| Featured | This quote was our Quote of the Day on December 28, 2024 |
More Quotes by Miles
Add to List
