"Justice is itself the great standing policy of civil society; and any eminent departure from it, under any circumstances, lies under the suspicion of being no policy at all"
About this Quote
Justice isn’t presented here as a moral accessory but as the load-bearing beam of the entire civic house. Burke’s phrasing is deliberately bureaucratic - “standing policy” - and that’s the trick: he translates an ethical claim into the language of governance, as if to tell fellow statesmen that justice isn’t what you do when convenient; it’s the default operating system that keeps the state from becoming a machine for arbitrary power.
The line “any eminent departure” does a lot of work. Burke isn’t denying that governments sometimes bend rules in crises; he’s warning that the bigger, flashier the exception, the less it deserves the name “policy.” It begins to look like impulse, factional interest, or panic dressed up as strategy. “Under any circumstances” tightens the screws: emergencies are the favorite pretext of executive overreach, and Burke is preemptively stripping that excuse of its glamour.
Context matters. Burke is the consummate critic of abstract political engineering - most famously of the French Revolution’s appetite for remaking society by theory and force. He’s also the parliamentary voice who prosecuted Warren Hastings and condemned abuses in British India. That pairing is key: Burke isn’t defending the status quo as such; he’s defending legitimacy. The subtext is a warning to power: once you normalize injustice for “reasons,” you don’t get clever policy, you get a state that has to keep inventing reasons. Justice, for Burke, is less about purity than about continuity - the only sustainable kind of authority.
The line “any eminent departure” does a lot of work. Burke isn’t denying that governments sometimes bend rules in crises; he’s warning that the bigger, flashier the exception, the less it deserves the name “policy.” It begins to look like impulse, factional interest, or panic dressed up as strategy. “Under any circumstances” tightens the screws: emergencies are the favorite pretext of executive overreach, and Burke is preemptively stripping that excuse of its glamour.
Context matters. Burke is the consummate critic of abstract political engineering - most famously of the French Revolution’s appetite for remaking society by theory and force. He’s also the parliamentary voice who prosecuted Warren Hastings and condemned abuses in British India. That pairing is key: Burke isn’t defending the status quo as such; he’s defending legitimacy. The subtext is a warning to power: once you normalize injustice for “reasons,” you don’t get clever policy, you get a state that has to keep inventing reasons. Justice, for Burke, is less about purity than about continuity - the only sustainable kind of authority.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Edmund
Add to List







