"Negotiations are a euphemism for capitulation if the shadow of power is not cast across the bargaining table"
About this Quote
Diplomacy, in George Shultz's telling, is never just talk; it's theater lit by the hard spotlight of leverage. The line is built around a deliberately acidic swap: what polite people call "negotiations" can, under the wrong conditions, become "capitulation". That euphemism jab does real work. It warns that language in foreign policy is often a comfort blanket for domestic audiences, a way to dignify outcomes that are actually surrender dressed up as process.
The subtext is classic Shultz: credibility is currency, and it has to be backed by something visible enough to shape the other side's expectations. "The shadow of power" is a carefully chosen metaphor. He doesn't demand that power be used, only that it be felt - a presence across the table that changes the math of refusal. Shadow implies restraint and ambiguity: you don't fire the gun, you leave it on the mantle where everyone can see it.
Context matters. Shultz served as Reagan's secretary of state in the late Cold War, when arms control, proxy conflicts, and hostage diplomacy exposed the limits of good faith bargaining. His experience produced a pragmatic skepticism about agreements not anchored in enforceable consequences. The sentence is also aimed inward, at a recurring American temptation: to treat negotiation as a moral posture rather than a strategic act. Shultz insists that without credible power - military, economic, political - the bargaining table tilts, and the only "agreement" available is the one the stronger party was already prepared to impose.
The subtext is classic Shultz: credibility is currency, and it has to be backed by something visible enough to shape the other side's expectations. "The shadow of power" is a carefully chosen metaphor. He doesn't demand that power be used, only that it be felt - a presence across the table that changes the math of refusal. Shadow implies restraint and ambiguity: you don't fire the gun, you leave it on the mantle where everyone can see it.
Context matters. Shultz served as Reagan's secretary of state in the late Cold War, when arms control, proxy conflicts, and hostage diplomacy exposed the limits of good faith bargaining. His experience produced a pragmatic skepticism about agreements not anchored in enforceable consequences. The sentence is also aimed inward, at a recurring American temptation: to treat negotiation as a moral posture rather than a strategic act. Shultz insists that without credible power - military, economic, political - the bargaining table tilts, and the only "agreement" available is the one the stronger party was already prepared to impose.
Quote Details
| Topic | Vision & Strategy |
|---|
More Quotes by George
Add to List




