"The nobler a man, the harder it is for him to suspect inferiority in others"
About this Quote
A person formed by high standards instinctively sees others through the lens of those standards. Integrity makes petty motives feel implausible; magnanimity assumes generosity elsewhere. Cicero captures a paradox of virtue: the better one becomes, the more alien baseness appears, and the harder it is to imagine that others could be moved by envy, malice, or small ambitions. This is not mere optimism; it is a moral blind spot that arises from the habit of ascribing to others the reasons that guide oneself.
As a statesman and moralist in the last, convulsive decades of the Roman Republic, Cicero championed the idea that public life must rest on virtue. In works like On Duties he argues that nobility of character yields trustworthy action, civic friendship, and lawful order. Yet his career also illustrates a cost of charitable judgment. He initially counted on the young Octavian to protect the Republic against Antony; Octavian soon joined Antony, and Cicero was proscribed and killed. The episode reads like a case study of the line: a noble faith in principled motives misread the hard calculus of power.
The reflection does not counsel cynicism. It urges the noble to add prudence to generosity, to remember that their inner compass is not universally shared. Friendship, leadership, and justice all require a presumption of good will, but they also require tests, institutions, and habits of verification. Nobility should include a trained attentiveness to signs of vanity, greed, or resentment, especially when flattery and common cause mask them. When charity governs intention and inquiry governs judgment, one avoids the naivete that vice exploits.
The saying ultimately diagnoses a projection error of the virtuous. To be truly noble is to keep one’s faith in human dignity while resisting the temptation to universalize one’s own motives. Charity without vigilance is not virtue; it is an invitation.
As a statesman and moralist in the last, convulsive decades of the Roman Republic, Cicero championed the idea that public life must rest on virtue. In works like On Duties he argues that nobility of character yields trustworthy action, civic friendship, and lawful order. Yet his career also illustrates a cost of charitable judgment. He initially counted on the young Octavian to protect the Republic against Antony; Octavian soon joined Antony, and Cicero was proscribed and killed. The episode reads like a case study of the line: a noble faith in principled motives misread the hard calculus of power.
The reflection does not counsel cynicism. It urges the noble to add prudence to generosity, to remember that their inner compass is not universally shared. Friendship, leadership, and justice all require a presumption of good will, but they also require tests, institutions, and habits of verification. Nobility should include a trained attentiveness to signs of vanity, greed, or resentment, especially when flattery and common cause mask them. When charity governs intention and inquiry governs judgment, one avoids the naivete that vice exploits.
The saying ultimately diagnoses a projection error of the virtuous. To be truly noble is to keep one’s faith in human dignity while resisting the temptation to universalize one’s own motives. Charity without vigilance is not virtue; it is an invitation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Humility |
|---|
More Quotes by Cicero
Add to List
