Famous quote by Byron White

"To exclude all jurors who would be in the slightest way affected by the prospect of the death penalty would be to deprive the defendant of the impartial jury to which he or she is entitled under the law"

About this Quote

The quote by Byron White resolves a complex concern within the legal system, especially worrying the choice of jurors in cases where the death sentence is a potential outcome. At its core, the statement highlights the tension in between making sure an unbiased jury and acknowledging the ethical and ethical ramifications that the death penalty may conjure up among possible jurors.

White's assertion recommends that attempting to leave out all jurors who might be affected by their views on the death penalty might weaken the really principle of an objective jury. The term "objective jury" refers to a group of jurors who are objective and uncolored, tasked with assessing the case based solely on the evidence provided in the courtroom. By recommending that jurors may be excluded for harboring any opinion on the death sentence, White raises a critical point about the expediency of accomplishing real impartiality. If jurors are to be completely dispassionate, then those who might oppose or support the death penalty on personal or ethical grounds might be seen as partial. However, individuals with no viewpoint whatsoever on such a dissentious concern might be unusual, if not difficult, to find.

White's quote suggests that the legal system should strike a balance where jurors can possess personal beliefs yet stay reasonable and committed to upholding the law. The judicial procedure recognizes that total objectivity is tough to obtain, but it emphasizes the value of jurors who can reserve their predispositions in favor of legal mandates and accurate evidence. For that reason, the choice procedure should ensure that jurors can distinguish between individual convictions and legal obligations.

Eventually, the quote recommends that the juridical goal should not be to get rid of all traces of human emotion or belief from the courtroom but to ensure that these components do not cloud fair judgment. This requires a nuanced method to jury selection, promoting for diversity in perspectives while maintaining a steadfast commitment to objective justice.

More details

TagsDeath

About the Author

USA Flag This quote is from Byron White between June 8, 1916 and April 15, 2002. He/she was a famous Judge from USA. The author also have 7 other quotes.
See more from Byron White

Similar Quotes

Shortlist

No items yet. Click "Add" on a Quote.