"When you argue with your inferiors, you convince them of only one thing: they are as clever as you"
About this Quote
Irving Layton distills a social paradox: once you descend to argue with someone you consider beneath you, you ratify their standing. Argument is not only a search for truth; it is a public ritual that confers legitimacy. By engaging, you signal that the other person is worth your time, that their claims deserve your rebuttal, and that the field of play is level. The result is not enlightenment but status inflation: they feel, and appear, as clever as you.
Layton, a Canadian poet famed for his combative wit, understood the theater of intellect. He relished debate, yet he also grasped its unintended consequences. The sharper mind does not always win in the arena of perception; the more visible combatant does. Especially before an audience, arguments can harden identities rather than shift positions. Your opponent may absorb none of your reasons but all of your recognition. The phrase only one thing is barbed hyperbole: it warns that the symbolic victory of being treated as a peer can eclipse any substantive loss on points.
The line also tests the arrogance hidden in the word inferiors. If you truly believe someone lacks the capacity for a fruitful exchange, why argue at all? Teach, if you can. Ignore, if you must. Arguing signals doubt about your own authority or a need to prove yourself, and that need is precisely what levels the hierarchy. The ego tries to dominate; the encounter democratizes.
There is a modern resonance in online discourse, where every reply boosts visibility and confers stature. Do not feed the troll is a folk echo of Laytons insight. Choose forums and interlocutors where reasons can matter, and where engagement elevates understanding rather than merely an opponent. Preserve the dignity of your position by conserving the currency of your attention.
Layton, a Canadian poet famed for his combative wit, understood the theater of intellect. He relished debate, yet he also grasped its unintended consequences. The sharper mind does not always win in the arena of perception; the more visible combatant does. Especially before an audience, arguments can harden identities rather than shift positions. Your opponent may absorb none of your reasons but all of your recognition. The phrase only one thing is barbed hyperbole: it warns that the symbolic victory of being treated as a peer can eclipse any substantive loss on points.
The line also tests the arrogance hidden in the word inferiors. If you truly believe someone lacks the capacity for a fruitful exchange, why argue at all? Teach, if you can. Ignore, if you must. Arguing signals doubt about your own authority or a need to prove yourself, and that need is precisely what levels the hierarchy. The ego tries to dominate; the encounter democratizes.
There is a modern resonance in online discourse, where every reply boosts visibility and confers stature. Do not feed the troll is a folk echo of Laytons insight. Choose forums and interlocutors where reasons can matter, and where engagement elevates understanding rather than merely an opponent. Preserve the dignity of your position by conserving the currency of your attention.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Irving
Add to List
