"Considered now as a possession, one may define culture as the residuum of a large body of useless knowledge that has been well and truly forgotten"
About this Quote
Nock skewers “culture” by treating it less as an active practice than as a social asset, something you can stash, display, and convert into status. The key move is his acidic redefinition: culture is not what you know, but what’s left over after you’ve forgotten most of what you once dutifully crammed into your mind. “Residuum” does the work here. It’s the sediment of education, the aftertaste of reading, the faint imprint of disciplines you can no longer recite on command. The jab is that a lot of what passes for refinement is built from “useless knowledge” acquired under the sign of obligation or vanity, then “well and truly forgotten” - conveniently, because forgetting lets you keep the aura without the burden of the details.
The subtext is a critique of credentialism and polite intellectual consumption. If culture is a “possession,” it behaves like property: it marks class boundaries, signals belonging, and reassures the owner of their own distinction. Nock implies that modern societies turn learning into an accumulative sport, mistaking the hoarding of information for the formation of judgment.
Context matters: Nock wrote as an anti-statist, anti-mass-society thinker in an America newly confident in its institutions of schooling, expertise, and upward mobility. His suspicion wasn’t of learning itself but of learning instrumentalized - education as a pipeline to respectability. The line is funny because it’s cruelly plausible: what survives in many “cultured” people isn’t a library in the head, but a posture, a taste, a reflex for what to admire.
The subtext is a critique of credentialism and polite intellectual consumption. If culture is a “possession,” it behaves like property: it marks class boundaries, signals belonging, and reassures the owner of their own distinction. Nock implies that modern societies turn learning into an accumulative sport, mistaking the hoarding of information for the formation of judgment.
Context matters: Nock wrote as an anti-statist, anti-mass-society thinker in an America newly confident in its institutions of schooling, expertise, and upward mobility. His suspicion wasn’t of learning itself but of learning instrumentalized - education as a pipeline to respectability. The line is funny because it’s cruelly plausible: what survives in many “cultured” people isn’t a library in the head, but a posture, a taste, a reflex for what to admire.
Quote Details
| Topic | Knowledge |
|---|
More Quotes by Albert
Add to List

