"What concerns me, is the general social tendency to enforce a level, above which nothing rises and stands out"
About this Quote
Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau points to a quiet but powerful pressure within modern societies: the impulse to sand down edges until no one or nothing dares to stand out. He is not attacking fairness or community; he is warning about a culture that confuses equality with sameness and turns suspicion on excellence. When visibility or distinction becomes a social offense, talent learns to whisper and ambition hides behind irony.
As a German baritone who transformed the art of song interpretation, Fischer-Dieskau knew how much effort and vulnerability it takes to rise above the ordinary. His career unfolded in postwar Germany, where democratic rebuilding often came with a wary attitude toward elitism. He witnessed a cultural landscape shaped by radio, records, and later television, forces that democratized access but also risked standardizing taste. The remark echoes an old worry in democratic thought, noted by observers from Tocqueville to modern critics of mass culture: the flattening of difference in the name of comfort.
The danger is not only external censorship but internal self-censorship. Artists, scholars, and professionals may lower their sights to avoid resentment, algorithms may privilege the safely familiar over the challenging new, and institutions may confuse inclusion with the removal of thresholds that demand excellence. A society that punishes the tall poppy ends with a field of cut stems.
True equality sets a floor, not a ceiling. It widens the path to distinction rather than closing the gates. Admiration, mentorship, and rigorous standards allow exceptional work to flourish without contempt for those still learning. The arts make this visible: a singular performance does not steal from others; it enlarges the audience for everyone. Fischer-Dieskau urges a stance of cultural courage, one that protects difference, honors mastery, and accepts that the presence of the extraordinary is not an insult to the average but a gift to the whole.
As a German baritone who transformed the art of song interpretation, Fischer-Dieskau knew how much effort and vulnerability it takes to rise above the ordinary. His career unfolded in postwar Germany, where democratic rebuilding often came with a wary attitude toward elitism. He witnessed a cultural landscape shaped by radio, records, and later television, forces that democratized access but also risked standardizing taste. The remark echoes an old worry in democratic thought, noted by observers from Tocqueville to modern critics of mass culture: the flattening of difference in the name of comfort.
The danger is not only external censorship but internal self-censorship. Artists, scholars, and professionals may lower their sights to avoid resentment, algorithms may privilege the safely familiar over the challenging new, and institutions may confuse inclusion with the removal of thresholds that demand excellence. A society that punishes the tall poppy ends with a field of cut stems.
True equality sets a floor, not a ceiling. It widens the path to distinction rather than closing the gates. Admiration, mentorship, and rigorous standards allow exceptional work to flourish without contempt for those still learning. The arts make this visible: a singular performance does not steal from others; it enlarges the audience for everyone. Fischer-Dieskau urges a stance of cultural courage, one that protects difference, honors mastery, and accepts that the presence of the extraordinary is not an insult to the average but a gift to the whole.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|
More Quotes by Dietrich
Add to List
