"A judgment about life has no meaning except the truth of the one who speaks last, and the mind is at ease only at the moment when everyone is shouting at once and no one can hear a thing"
About this Quote
Bataille rigs this line like a philosophical knife fight: whoever speaks last gets to call it truth, not because theyre right, but because theyre standing. The first clause takes a swing at the fantasy of stable moral verdicts. Judgments about life dont live in some neutral court of reason; theyre social events, power plays, timed to whoever controls the ending. In the shadow of two world wars and the collapse of European certainties, that cynicism isnt just attitude - its reportage.
Then he turns and makes the more perverse claim: the mind finds peace not in clarity, but in total noise. Everyone shouting at once and no one hearing anything is a nightmare scenario for democratic deliberation, yet Bataille frames it as relief. Thats the subtext: argument is exhausting because it pretends to be about truth while really being about domination. When the room becomes pure cacophony, the pretense collapses. No one can win, so the pressure to win evaporates. Silence, for him, isnt serenity; its the tense quiet where hierarchy reforms and the last speaker readies their verdict.
This is Batailles broader project in miniature: he distrusts tidy rationalism and keeps looking for the point where meaning breaks under strain - in excess, taboo, transgression. The quote isnt advice. Its a diagnosis of how people use language to seize the final word, and how the psyche sometimes prefers breakdown to another round of polished, civilized coercion.
Then he turns and makes the more perverse claim: the mind finds peace not in clarity, but in total noise. Everyone shouting at once and no one hearing anything is a nightmare scenario for democratic deliberation, yet Bataille frames it as relief. Thats the subtext: argument is exhausting because it pretends to be about truth while really being about domination. When the room becomes pure cacophony, the pretense collapses. No one can win, so the pressure to win evaporates. Silence, for him, isnt serenity; its the tense quiet where hierarchy reforms and the last speaker readies their verdict.
This is Batailles broader project in miniature: he distrusts tidy rationalism and keeps looking for the point where meaning breaks under strain - in excess, taboo, transgression. The quote isnt advice. Its a diagnosis of how people use language to seize the final word, and how the psyche sometimes prefers breakdown to another round of polished, civilized coercion.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Georges
Add to List









